POLL: Real or fake Christmas tree?

9 years ago

last modified: 9 years ago

A lot of people argue that the real thing is the best thing, but when it comes to Christmas trees, there's often a bit of switching sides. You can't beat the smell of a real Christmas tree, but then you can't argue against the tidiness and longevity of a fake tree.

What did you go for this year? The real thing or its tidier little brother? Vote and let us know why!

Norton Priory · More Info

A real tree of course!

A fake tree is just as good!

Other

Featured Answer

User

7 years ago

It has to be a live tree for me!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (50)

Luisa Rollenhagen
9 years ago
I'm a purist, real tree all the way. Up until a couple of years ago my dad and I would even drive out into the forest every year to a location where we could cut down our own tree!
Tony McIntyre
9 years ago
I have a fake tree, which I've had for a few years. When it's time to get a new one, I will definitely be getting a real one!
Related Discussions
Share your Christmas traditions!
Q
Comments (49)
Family traditions My grandparents from the 1930s until 1980s used to own a popular shop in a small town. Throughout this time my grandmother would increase her turnover every christmas by creating the most amazing handmade tree Angels and artisan crackers. From September until December it was a tradition of fairy and cracker making. I loved the glitzy fabrics,netting and bright tinsel that adorned the fairies. The cracker making was great fun the smell of the crackers when pulled was nothing like today. Just like Fortnum and Masons my grandmothers Christmas window display would be unveiled at the beginning of December,people would flock to buy her Angels and crackers. I never had one of the fairies and I often wonder if any are still in use today, I hope there is somewhere,in some ones home adorning a tree at the top loved by all as a tradition in memory of my grandmother. Sadly my grandparents are no longer here though the tradition of Christmas cracker pulling reminds me of the excitement and joy at Christmas pulling one of their crackers. Today nothing else cuts the mustard, even though I follow the tradition of making my own, of course I know what's inside. I hope my daughters and grand daughters will follow the family tradition in cracker making one day too. Peace and goodwill to all Ginny
...See More
Show us your Christmas tree!
Q
Comments (60)
Decorating the tree is always the beginning of something special in our house. Nothing eases the stresses and strains of planning like rummaging through the boxes looking for that special, favourite bauble. We all have our own and each of the children have theirs too. These 3 are my favourite; baby Jesus for our son James, white first Christmas bauble for our daughter Sophie and Rudolph for Mummy & Daddy. Merry Christmas everyone.
...See More
POLL: Bungalow - love or loathe?
Q
Comments (85)
Yes that was one of the issues with our place. Narrow corridors, poorly lit. But by rearranging the access to key spaces, blocking some doors and creating a new double width doorway to the principle room, what was a narrow hallway is now integrated and useful. By converting the large loft, we now have a stairwell lit by two velux windows which also throw light into the heart of the building. Lastly the old underhouse garage is now a studio, glazed with full height blue-grey aluminium windows and a door. Our originally depressing, generic ittle bungalow on a sloping site has become a four bed live-work space on three levels that is beginning to feel more like our home
...See More
Real or Fake? What type of Christmas tree do you have?
Q
Comments (6)
We have one of each. The real on goes in the sitting room and is carefully decorated, all colour coordinated, and meticulously done by the wife. In the conservatory we have the fake one which is decorated by the kids - so it looks like a tinsel factory has exploded, baubles of all shapes/sizes/colours randomly bunched everywhere, flashing lights, tacky beads/bells. You can only make out a tiny bit of green tree under all the stuff (I absolutely love it, it's got so much character, but I'll still go in there any tidy it up a bit when the kids are in bed as most of it is only 'decorated' up to my waist height, so I do move some of it to the top 1/2 of the tree. Got to love the smell of a real tree as well
...See More
Sonia Goul-Wheeker
9 years ago
A real tree definitely! It's a yearly tradition for my dad and I to go choose the Christmas tree and spend ages picking one out that's just right. Personally, it wouldn't feel right to have a fake tree!
em2020
9 years ago
Fake all the way - everyone thinks it's real anyway. Just drag it out year after year. It's only a month out of the year so no extra expense, no hassle going and getting the thing in the cold.. Straight up, decorated, job done in a couple of hours. Away in the attic afterwards instead of disposal of a beautiful real tree.
Resistance
9 years ago
we love our techno LED Christmas tree ...
lislondon
9 years ago
You would never ever find an artificial Christmas tree in my house. For me it has to be the real thing! However, our tradition (Danish) we never get the tree into the house until the 22nd, so it's fresh and also, it has to be fresh, as we add lots of live candles to our tree! Keep making sure to top up the water in the bucket in which the tree sits, and you'll have a beautiful and fresh tree over the Christmas period right until the 6th January when Christmas is over... :) Happy Christmas... :)
soozmacrae
9 years ago
I have a fake tree, its black in colour to go with my living room, but I really prefer a real tree.
twistlike
9 years ago
we have and artificial that either goes in the hall or the dining room and had real trees in the lounge for years-made a big thing of getting it, but it used to take me so long to choose 'the right tree', couldn't decide it was a full day job. for the last few years we've just used the fake one, my daughter who has special needs put the artificial in the hall this year, it was lovely to come home from work to find her and her dad had done all the arrangements for me.
Carol Weston
9 years ago
I'd always choose real, but my beloved is horribly allergic so fake it has to be (sigh).
whiggygirl
9 years ago
Pine needles are toxic to cats, so you will NEVER find a real tree in my house! I have a fibre-optic tree, SO therapeutic!
PRO
Pines and Needles
7 years ago
Our sustainable Real Trees are the way to go- Grown in our Scottish plantations.

You cannot beat the smell and look of a real Nordmann Fir
minnie101
7 years ago
I'd always had real trees growing up so continued with that until a few years ago when I ruined our new wood floor by watering the tree. We splashed out on 2 of the real feel trees and I have to say I really like them. No more spending hours at the garden centre choosing the perfect tree and working out if you can get it home plus I'm allergic to them so although decorating was fun it was painful on my hands! I think you need a tree skirt with an artificial one though. I might put a real one in my porch this year though...
PRO
Pines and Needles
7 years ago
We always encourage our customers to buy a water holding stand as it has a good holding capacity and it wide to help with ease of topping up. Also we recommend putting the water in the stand before installing the tree and removing the netting.

We hand pick your premium tree and deliver it to your door and if you live in the London area we will also install & decorate for an additional cost.

We also sell tree skirts and stand mats to protect your flooring ;-)

We sell lovely potted trees and pots if you would like one for your porch- take a look at our website:https://www.pinesandneedles.com/

Or visit our stores page:https://www.pinesandneedles.com/christmas-trees-london
lislondon
7 years ago
Being Danish, and having been brought up with the real thing, I could never ever have anything else. The difference to an English Christmas tree and a Danish Christmas tree is, that we only bring the fresh tree inside a few days before the 24th...where we celebrate our Danish Christmas, and with lots of live candles on the tree..and yes, it's completely safe, as the tree is fresh, it's foot is in water...and that's what we Danes do...and we are so lucky, as we also celebrate our English Christmas on the 25th...and now we are in Provence, we do exactly the same...❤️
lisa77226
7 years ago
I like to put it up really early (been known to do it in the last week of November) so we can enjoy the festive feeling in the lead up so I do a fake tree. I also take it down promptly on Boxing Day. Even if I wanted to do real, I grew up with cats that liked to climb it and now have a dog who wouldn't hesitate to lift his leg on it! I'm sticking with fake!
PRO
Pines and Needles
7 years ago
If you keep your real tree cool and watered it will last up to four weeks....

don't let pets prevent you from enjoying a real tree - we advise using shatterproof decorations to avoid breakage and attach with wire twist hooks to secure

Gift your pet a mini tree to play with and invest in a potted tree or 4ft Nord for your bedroom or porch...Give it go - you will not be disappointed

Here's a code you for you to use online:

REAL

**add at checkout on your order and you will get a mini tree and mistletoe as a gift from us

www.pinesandneedles.com
lisa77226
7 years ago
I like the look of real trees but they're just not for me.
wallielo
7 years ago
we have 2 trees (a small forest - sorry!) the one for the sitting room is massive (fake) dark green with little bits of snow that are found throughout the house in january. but we love it, takes an age to put it up and decorate and five minutes to take back down. we have a small tree for the kitchen which is white and about 4 foot high and the most miserable looking little thing you've ever seen. we have it since we got married and were broke (still broke and still married ha) and my little adopted nieces come over on Christmas eve (one who is alergic to the real thing) and we decorate it and laugh and joke. every year we choose a new decoration for their deceased daddy and smile at the "old" ones, and more often than not it gets knocked over by their mammy after a few mulled wines and it has to be taken apart and redone. great craic for the kids, funny how it is somehow decorated differently every time.
PRO
Nolte Kitchens UK
7 years ago
In the current climate, everything that can be recycled should. This is true of a real tree!
PRO
Wood4Floors
7 years ago
Real tree would be great!
PRO
Studio Kitty McKibbin
7 years ago
Real, real, real all the way!
Stephen Edwards
7 years ago
I always used to have a real tree, I love the look, the smell, the size. I don't like the clearing up after it, or the dog thinking I have brought the outside in for him. I stopped having a real one in my last house as I didn't have the space and bought a fake tree with built in fibre-optic lights, I used it last year in this house and it did look a bit silly so this year may go back to a real one
Tom Flanagan
Original Author
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
I agree, the mess is a pain but the smell makes it all worthwhile. Pine is just the best scent though I can never understand why things supposedly 'pine scented' are so terrible - it never smells remotely like pine!
PRO
Bio Fires
7 years ago
Nothing beats the real thing :)
PRO
Decor Kitchens & Bathrooms
7 years ago
Love the smell of a real tree!
PRO
Brooklands Property Holdings
7 years ago
You just can't beat a real tree!
PRO
PHIL FRANKLIN LANDSCAPES
7 years ago
Real tree every year!!
Rachael Fletcher
7 years ago
You can't beat the smell of a real tree!
PRO
fabricport.com
7 years ago
Always real - the smell, the funky shapes and all that comes with it! No artificial tree can beat a real tree and yes I do agree they can be a bit messy but its only once a year!
Maggie Booth
7 years ago
We love real but my son has very bad allergy to it, we had to rake him to A&E and he needed to stay there for days. So we have a fake tree but it looks very convincing , loads of our family have seen it but all thought it was real
hounoc
7 years ago
I honestly don't know any more. I used to always say real but the last few real ones we've had have had no smell (annoyingly as that's the best bit) and have been awkward shapes. Two years ago we had no tree until I cracked on the 23rd and went out and got a very realistic artificial one (NOT pre-decorated - I reserve at least that pleasure) and to be honest, I think I might be a convert. I've discovered that the only thing I really miss about the real ones are the smell which aren't a guarantee seemingly any more - I don't know what strange species our local sellers were getting but they aren't like the Christmas trees of yore...
Tom Flanagan
Original Author
7 years ago
I agree on all the above however I've never actually had a fake tree so maybe I should test the waters this year...
PRO
Tom Graham Workshop
7 years ago
If it doesn't smell like a tree it isn't Christmas, right?
PRO
Amber Jeavons Ltd
7 years ago
REAL + ROOTS = GR8 CHRISTMAS ! Post christmas... plant! Then next christmas.........REAL + ROOTS = GR8 CHRISTMAS ! Post christmas....plant! Then next christmas.... REAL + ROOTS = GR8 CHRISTMAS ! >>>>>>
PRO
GR Concept
7 years ago
Get a real one! It has a fresh organic scent that will add more christmasy feel in your space! :)
Phil Smith
7 years ago
Got to be a real one every time.
Gaynor Wall
7 years ago
I like to get a real tree but one that is still growing in the pot, then it can go out into the garden and bought back in next year. Its such a shame to cut a tree down. However all trees are beautiful whether they are fake or real when love has gone into arranging them. My best friend and i always buy each other a new decoration each year and its a delight to unwrap them and appreciate them as they are put in place xx
uree N
7 years ago
For countries that don't grow as much green .... Then the fibre I would rather call it than fake is the best plus less fear of shedding and all.
Sonia
7 years ago
Fake for me. Had a real tree years ago which shed pine needles constantly and made a dreadful mess. Also let's not forget people with asthma or allergies to grass and trees can become very ill. My 25 yr old niece decided to have a real tree one year and was so ill - breathing problems as well as streaming eyes and nose. If you have children with asthma, it may be better to choose a fake tree.
PRO
Normanton Designs
7 years ago
Fake Christmas trees are just wrong! Part of Christmas is that great smell of pine, not to mention the annual pilgrimage to buy the perfect tree each year. The fact that it won't last enhances the magic by making you appreciate it more.
jonesy100000000
7 years ago
I have a fake one as it was left in the roof by the previous owner which saved me having to go out and buy one, real or otherwise.
Tim Summers
7 years ago
We've gone for one of each again this year. I'd echo the sentiments of the smell of the real tree being almost magical.

The real tree is in the sitting room - and this is basically the wife's. She has full control over this bad-boy. She chooses the decorations, the lights, where things go, what colour scheme (for some reason the lights in this picture look blue. They're not, they're just a different 'white' - phone cameras hey).

The fake tree is in the kids room (aka the conservatory) - this is decorated by the kids, and basically they just stand there and throw as much stuff as they can get their hands on in the direction of the tree and see what sticks. I did have to wait till they went to bed to 're-locate' some of the accessories, as 90% of is was only decorated up to waist level.
Olena Tkach
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
A good fake one. I don't like to watch a tree slowly dying in my room. I don't like all the needles found in the most unexpected places till summer. I don't have a garden to plant a tree there. We're a very clumpsy family and we don't remove decorations till February, so anyway a real tree never survives the holiday season, so renting a tree in a pot is not an option too.

So, a good fake tree and some aromatic oils and sachets for the smell.
User
7 years ago
real tree!
PRO
Manuka Roofing Ltd
7 years ago
real tree!!!!!
PRO
Hana Snow
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Always real, the smell, the touch. Bring the outside in!
PRO
BuzziSpace
7 years ago
A fake one could be far more creative
Doe Stewart
7 years ago
Definitely a real tree although I have no idea how our 10 month old border terrier is going to behave when he sees ours for the first time As long as he doesn't think we have brought him an inside toilet in the lounge and doesn't try to take the fairy off the top we'll be OK. Wish us luck
PRO
MBH Carpentry and Joinery Ltd.
7 years ago
Always grew up with a fake tree and have now older carried on with that. My dreams lead me to have a posh house that would warrant a real tree.

POLL: Real or fake Christmas tree?

Comments (50)

Related Discussions

Tom FlanaganOriginal Author

Tom FlanaganOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Tom Flanagan
Original Author

Tom Flanagan
Original Author