Bedroom dilemma - lose the sink, fireplace, both or neither?

8 years ago

We're renovating an old-person's 1930s built house and have a north facing room I'd like to make into a guest bedroom. It has a pink sink and a greeny fireplace - both appear to be originals but what can I do to make this warm and welcoming? The curtains and carpet are going! I'm not keen on removing original pieces, but I'm really stuck for ideas and colours. We can maybe recoat the sink to be white - does anyone have any suggestions to help me? Thanks.

Featured Answer

mrskain1

8 years ago

I risk sounding insensitive, but the sink and the fireplace thing are not very appealing and I'm not sure why you'd keep them. I'd take out the sink, add a door for a closet. I'd just remove the fireplace completely, fix the hole and you'd have a look nice room.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (58)

headers13
8 years ago
It depends if you like it. I personally don't & as above then you might then want to keep/have character features all through the house. All depends if you want that look.
maccoops thanked headers13
timiduser
8 years ago
Yes, get rid of the sink. People don't have sinks in their bedrooms nowadays.
maccoops thanked timiduser
Related Discussions
Small Terraced House Ground Floor Extension Dilemma
Q
Comments (13)
Wow! Thanks for the comments so far. It's great to get all these different perspectives. Where to start? So one important thing to mention is that we're really tight on our budget. I figured that the most cost effective option would be to keep the current kitchen where it is which I figured only really gives us option 1 or option 2. I wonder how much more expensive it would be to have a totally different design? The original house didn't have a bathroom upstairs but we managed to squeeze one in when we renovated the upstairs while still keeping 3 bedrooms. So this is the original bathroom downstairs. I wanted to keep a small toilet and shower at least for when the kids get a bit older or if we have guests. The pictures of sofas in the living room and extension are a bit optimistic. I'd be quite happy to have one sofa in the living room and one in the extension. Sophie, our builder recommended we keep the window in the bathroom if possible, but this means making the extension a bit less wide - not by much, but perhaps enough to make a difference. The actual side passage wall is the same in both options. We could ditch the window in the wider bathroom option actually and keep the same width of extension. His point about keeping (or having) a window was that it'd be good to have some natural ventilation and daylight in there. We checked the head height and it'd be enough for a shower. I kind of prefer option 1 from a flow point of view, but I'm very concerned about the door opening straight into the kitchen. Alky, I can't really see much detail in your pictures, are you able to upload something a bit higher res? From what I can see, it certainly looks like a big and creative change. The funny thing is that one of the neighbours whose house is pretty nearly identical to this design (apart from the toilet/bathroom) their house looks pretty awesome. But now I'm confused because you've all raised very valid points which make me wonder about the whole design.
...See More
Should we keep our old fireplaces?
Q
Comments (34)
The Edwardian fireplace is the correct proportion and age for the house. Hard to tell if it is actually original to the house or if it is Mahogany or Oak, but don't paint it. Wood has a beauty of its own if treated with a natural finish like Beeswax and the patina of age adds to the beauty. Certainly don't varnish it. One of the reasons it appears heavy in the photo is the oak surround on the hearth tiles. My advice would be to remove the wood hearth surround and install a wood floor in the room (perhaps oak and slightly lighter in colour than the fireplace butting up to the tiled hearth). This will will compliment the fireplace and ground it. You could remove the tiles (normally I would keep original tiles) but the cream and maroon colours in this instance do give an overall heaviness and don't particularly enhance the fireplace, however I would leave the tiles for the moment. The finished scheme should look classy and elegant with a neutral colour palette. If this is going to be a working fireplace than you may consider a grey slate hearth. This is the focal point of your room so getting it right is key. Wherever possible conserve original features. The 1930's fireplace on the opposite side would appear original and most likely installed in the 30's. It is charming but not proportionally correct for an Edwardian house. But because it tells a story and is original I would be loath to remove it. Selling it on would be tricky as the tiles will most likely damage when removing them. I would keep both fireplaces as they will both sit well in a neutral colour scheme with a wooden floor.
...See More
Fireplace dilemma
Q
Comments (40)
Hi Cherie. Yes I love it. I sent the houzz tour it featured on to my husband and he said it would be our dream home! Thanks for the info and the fire details, I didn't even think of a stud chimney! I'm not sure it would work for ours, the room is 17 x 18 but the chimney breast is 51cm already so it's pretty deep. (Once I work out how to remove a couple of test bricks I may be pleasantly surprised and find the fire there as the hearth is still under the carpet!). what are your thoughts on it working in the room? IF the paper stayed the plaster would be greys and antique gold
...See More
Can't decide between 2 floor plans...
Q
Comments (23)
@kikamack, many thanks for your thoughts. My kitchen layout was just a quick one - it's not finalised but the fridge/freezer would go with the tall oven unit is and I would probably just have the oven underneath the hob instead for ease. We didn't want high wall units as we want to go for a more Industrial style and less kitchen looking. We are considering a peninsula depending on the outside door location though. Re the plan - we are looking to add perhaps an extra wc downstairs & making a wider hall, but, after having spent a full day/evening yesterday going through all different options ie kitchen in the dining room, we decided that we really prefer the lounge in that section as I have it on the plan with the larger bathroom. Main reasons being:- we don't have to remove the chimney breast, we still have access to all the storage space under the stairs (not shown on the pic) and it means we can have 2 sides of windows/doors at the back if the dining table is there (which we couldn't if it was the living area due to needing space for a log burner and tv wall) which will overlook a wrap around garden. We have an entire house to pretty much rebuild (needs a new roof, upstairs all re-doing as not insulated and a new bathroom/dressing room) plus gardens to landscape and the outbuilding renovating to use as a home office/granny flat. Phew. So we need to do the least disruptive amount of work to gain the best plan for us. I quite like the kitchen idea of in the dining space but my husband hates it and he rarely hates things so I don't want to push him on it
...See More
maccoops
Original Author
8 years ago
Thanks very much everyone; the house has fire places in just about every room, this is probably the least pretty and all the other bedrooms had sinks of varying colours in them too, which we've removed. I think it might be best to remove the sink and maybe keep the fire place. Debs Morris - I have lovely duck egg curtains already that are too good to throw away which might work in there, so you've given me a line of thought. MarisaRosado - room is full of boxes at the minute - these are old photos of when we first moved in, but thanks, I think your suggestion is a good one. Thanks again everyone - all good feedback. :)
PRO
Ikonografik Design
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Agree with other people on here. Lose the sink and towel rail, make the recess into a cupboard / wardrobe with a new door. The fire place is nice general design but the colours look dated. Possibly retain the fireplace appearance but re-tile with new contemporary tiles and colours, retain the ribbed back tiles though as they could offer a nice contrast. Possibly put a mirror above fireplace? If you insulate the horizontal hole in the chimney opening you could also re-tile the interior of the fireback and use as storage or put somethinng decorative in the recess. Suggest you also get the electrics re-done as current regs don't permit sockets in skirtings due to increased fire risk.
maccoops thanked Ikonografik Design
PRO
Platonic Fireplace Company
8 years ago
Get rid of both and go for something new and modern! Depending on your taste and how the rest of the house looks. check out our website for fireplace inspiration! http://platonicfireplaces.co.uk/
maccoops thanked Platonic Fireplace Company
gilliifer
8 years ago
I would lose the sink as it looks out of proportion, replace with nice shelving. Keep the fireplace and paint the wall behind in a deep sage green with a deco mirror. Keep everything simple and pared back.
maccoops thanked gilliifer
Lauren
8 years ago
The sink is actually pretty classic and could be reused in another bathroom/cloakroom - as you suggest it's not impossible to re coat it white. Depends if you have another space for it.

I love fireplaces on bedrooms, they add a glamorous focal feature - but that one simply isn't a nice example of 1930's fireplaces. Personally I would try and find a more appealing wood framed 1930's one - perhaps leaning towards edwardian and swap them out. If you keep an eye out for local eBay deals you can often pick up nice examples that only need a lick of paint for very little money.
maccoops thanked Lauren
Alexandra Myers
8 years ago
Personally, lf the room is large enough, l would remove the fireplace (recycle or sell) and put an en suite in the corner of the room - shower, toilet and the sink. You have a connection already there so this could cost about £1500 - £2000 depending on the quality of materials. This is a welcome treat for any guest, adds value to your home and should you wish to, would make money for you if you ever want to get a lodger. In the new budget proposals you can have up to £7500 of rental income from your own home completely tax free. (I advise you NOT to use a saniflow toilet!)
maccoops thanked Alexandra Myers
suesigngirl
8 years ago
I love both the sink and the fireplace but you need to make this room suit your needs. If you are getting rid of both maybe advertise both as 'pre loved' and let someone pay you to take them away. Good luck with whatever you decide!
maccoops thanked suesigngirl
PRO
Amber Jeavons Ltd
8 years ago
Hello maccoops,

Consider re situating the sink elsewhere as it is rather nice, or if not sell it. Put a door on the frame and paint the colour of the walls so it blends.. whatever you decide.. A small closet or shelving inside. Leave the fireplace it's rather nice and with wooden floors stained or even painted could look really good actually. Think original features should be retained where possible and as the fire is from the period in which the house was built, should ideally remain!

Plenty you can do to make this room modern though and lovely.. : ))
maccoops thanked Amber Jeavons Ltd
gg38
8 years ago
I love the carpet in this room! Its gorgeous, what a shame to replace it ! I think its the nicest feature in the room and as they don't make that lovely floral style anymore, I'd be basing the scheme around that and re-use the sink elsewhere. Fireplaces in any room are a bonus but especially in a bedroom. I'm all for retaining original features. If you like the fireplace then keep it at the very least replace with another fireplace maybe not deco style but do not take away the fireplace altogether. I have a guest bedroom that is north facing and F&B cinder rose paint on the lime plaster walls looks fab in there and would work with your carpet!! PS. please bring your new curtains to the floor. Good luck!
maccoops thanked gg38
stillsmiling
8 years ago
Laura Ashley do nice wallpapers in green and pink which would link both features
maccoops thanked stillsmiling
Rob
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
looking at it, that sink looks like an original 1930s one. if you really want to get rid of it, sell it as they are now going for decent money on eBay and they as they are very sought after. I got a two piece primrose yellow 1955 "art deco style" loo and basin and they look amazing. I would not re-enamel it at all - white sanitaryware is so boring now, I've had enough of it. If you are anywhere near London I will buy if off you!
maccoops thanked Rob
mendhouse
8 years ago
SINK: Yes, defo put in a mini ensuite shower room as it will add value to the house (- if the room is too small can you steal extra space from whatever room is behind the sink?)

If not, make it into a closet or a bookshelf.

SHOWER: Fireplaces are nice in the bedroom but this one could do with changing or disguising unless you are going for vintage retro. feel which could be fun and save money. It all depends on your budget. Feel free to email me:

info@mendinghouses.com / www.mendinghouses.com

(this was a retro fireplace - I had the hearth removed and covered the front with white shells and a couple of ceramic roses.

www.mendinghouses.com
maccoops thanked mendhouse
marionb10
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I'd keep the fireplace and remove the sink. Paint the opposite wall in the green colour to compliment the fireplace green, change carpet and curtains to a neutral grey/green, floor length curtains, and put a door on the sink space to make a cupboard which it looks like it was originally. Accessorise with teal or turquoise to lift the scheme. You could always paint the fireplace tiles to a colour you prefer if you don't like the green/beige look.
maccoops thanked marionb10
pinklark
8 years ago
If budget and room allow I would suggest a small en-suite - it would be invaluable when you have guests and with water pipes already there may cost a lot less than you think and would add value to your property
maccoops thanked pinklark
chalkandbell
8 years ago
I love your room as it is and would keep the fireplace, sink and carpet! I could easily decorate and furnish to complement all three but if the vintage thing isn't your style I would say keep just the fireplace (pleeeeease!) and the sell the sink and carpet on eBay so someone else can enjoy them. I've just bought a 30's house with fireplaces in the bedrooms and it was one of the things I most loved about the house and as you've mentioned that you have others I'm sure they contributed to your decision to purchase too. I just need to replace the two 60's monstrosities downstairs now :-)
maccoops thanked chalkandbell
PRO
Pat Oliver Interior Design
8 years ago
I suspect that the wall between the fireplace and the window is false, as there will be another recess there. That's why the curtain is crammed into the corner. Remove the sink and architrive around it, remove the false wall and you will have restored the framework of the room. Your window treatment will look much better when you do it.

If you like the fireplace, then keep it. If you don't, then you could replace it with another whose style is in keeping with the property. Electric fires would be safest. And of course, an easy chair and reading lamp.
maccoops thanked Pat Oliver Interior Design
maggieandrichard
8 years ago
Please get rid of both.
maccoops thanked maggieandrichard
alva35
8 years ago
I would take out the terrible dull tile fire place. The sink could come in handy and I rather like the colour and the shape. he room needs a definite make over IF IT IS TO BE A comfortable bed room.
maccoops thanked alva35
rgarfoot
8 years ago
Think it depends on the interior styling of the rest of your home and if you want to follow the same theme through to this guest room. As long as they are in good condition you could retain them and match with Art Deco decoration and styling. i think if they are original its a shame to remove them. I wouldn't suggest trying to change the sink colour - i am not sure you would get a good enough finish to it. Look at investing in some good lighting as this will help to make the room feel warm and inviting. Consider using some art deco inspired wallpaper to that wall and make a real feature of it and changing the dark coloured joinery to a lighter shade. Good luck with your project
maccoops thanked rgarfoot
drpepe101
8 years ago
The sink is a bit of an anachronism in a bedroom these days, so I would remove. As Pat mentions above I would investigate the other side of the fireplace and reinstate any Alcove. A bit of balance will do wonders for the fireplace. Even better fitted wardrobes or shelves either side.
maccoops thanked drpepe101
Ruth M
8 years ago
If you've already got fireplaces but removed sinks in the other rooms then I would do the opposite in this room. If its not to be a master bedroom the sink would be a wonderful asset, as well as a novel one, for visitors, or even a child's room for a bedtime face wash and teeth scrub. Visitors would appreciate the ease of their own sink for midnight drinks and not invading your bathroom space.
I would refresh the whole sink area with a white(ish?) colour scheme and over mirror lights and a sleek low key towel rad replacement. And obviously loose the pink door frame. Would be beautiful.
maccoops thanked Ruth M
PRO
Concept Online Design
8 years ago
As you want the room as a guest room and have already got the plumbing in place have you thought about putting a shower in the room and removing the sink and fireplace. It would be very welcoming for your guests. Perhaps there is enough room in the closet to put a shower tray with a sliding glass door?
maccoops thanked Concept Online Design
alyper
8 years ago
Keep the fireplace, change the sink to a modern slim one, and put in mirror/shelves above, door put on, nice little washing / makeup area. Could be turned into a little gem!
maccoops thanked alyper
pkacharters
8 years ago
a washbasin in any bedroom especially a guest room is a real bonus. I had a beautiful dark blue one in my teenage bedroom. The black splashback is what needs to go. some complimentary tiles and decor would totally uplift the room and make it very pretty without losing the original character.
maccoops thanked pkacharters
Jonathan
8 years ago
All that matters is that the person who is going to enjoy the renovation likes the end result.

If you are going to live in the house then do you like the fireplace? If you are renovating to sell on then you need to think about what the next buyer will most need- most likely this will be storage and the fireplace could limit furniture placement.
maccoops thanked Jonathan
PRO
Bio Fires
8 years ago
If you like the fireplace then keep it. However if you keep the fireplace then the interior design of the whole room will be dictated by the green and art-deco style of the fireplace. If that does not suit the design style you have in mind I would suggest replacing the fireplace with a bio ethanol insert, in that way you can easily construct it in the room, with the choice of many different styles. A real flame fireplace will add a warm and welcoming ambience to the guestroom.

The sink does not add to the design of the room but as a guest room, a sink would be appreciated for its practical benefit, so perhaps something to consider.

You can visit our profile for some great ideas on fireplaces.
maccoops thanked Bio Fires
Jo Arnold
8 years ago
I think the sink is lovely (apart from the colour) so I'd be tempted to re enamel it or sell it to someone who would love it if you're really not keen.
maccoops thanked Jo Arnold
ganevitch
8 years ago
We have just moved into 1930s house, with sink in one corner of the room, and walk-in shower fitted retrospectively in a cupboard. We have not used either in 6 months (in spite of sharing one bathroom between 4 of us). To me it just feels odd washing in a bedroom, though visitors really appreciate the sink in their room when they visit.
I would not touch the fireplace - what is to the right of the fireplace though? Can that be made into an alcove like on the left?
It all boils down to taste - there was a before/after on Houzz recently where the fireplaces and pictures rails were all removed, walls painted white, with huge TV in chimney breast. If you want/like 1930s, keep them, if you want modern, get rid of them.
maccoops thanked ganevitch
Petite Maison
8 years ago
Both need to go on ebay!
maccoops thanked Petite Maison
PRO
User
8 years ago
I think it would be a shame to get rid of either as they are both key period features of the room. Take a look at the Malcolm Campbell room of the Burgh Island Hotel http://www.burghisland.com/rooms/campbell.html . If you choose the fireplace or sink colour for the main room colour and accent with the other it should look fab. I would also drop the curtains to the floor and if possible start them from the corner of the room rather than encroaching on the feature wall to help balance and segment it.
maccoops thanked User
maccoops
Original Author
8 years ago
Thanks for really helpful comments - much appreciated.
2dogssashatess
8 years ago
can be handy to have a sink in th bathroom. Can get a glass of water, brush ones teeth. if one felt sick and had to vomit could vomit in sink. I like the shape of the sink:) and the pink and black is fine. I'm not so keen on fire place but it is not important whether we like these things its whether you like them.
maccoops thanked 2dogssashatess
User
8 years ago
Seriously - do not remove them!!!!!!!!! I love them both - they are design classics. Spend an hour or too watching a BBC Agatha Christie production to get a true appreciation of art deco interiors and how beautiful they can be. The walls can be the palest of shell pink, with pastel blue/green curtains - it will look lovely.
maccoops thanked User
Charlotte
8 years ago

We're also renovating a 1930s house trying to keep as many original features as possible, but making it a lot more light and airy (think 1930s meets Scandinavian) - the fireplaces are a massive bonus to keep but it really depends how modern you want your home to be, and how colourful. As an example you could paint the fireplace tiles like we did (see photo) - we just need to refinish (lighten) the surround now (and add skirting boards, shelving, and about a million other things...) Though our fireplace was a vile colour so really couldn't be left as it was, yours looks good enough to be left as it is (maybe with neutral flooring) if you're happy for a more '30s vibe. The sink is beautiful but seems a waste in a bedroom - could it be moved to another bathroom? And probably refinished in white...
maccoops thanked Charlotte
Charlotte
8 years ago
However that said if it's a guest bedroom, guests may be grateful (and surprised!) to have their own sink.
pkacharters
8 years ago
Curious to know if you made a decision and how it turned out?
maccoops
Original Author
8 years ago
Not yet - we had planned to start clearing the room (it is full of boxes at the moment) but have had roofing problems - 2 big leaks at opposite ends of the house with all this rain - so can't move boxes to attic! I've had lots of great ideas from this site though and thinking will keep both - that decision may change tomorrow, ha ha. Thanks for asking. Will hopefully post an 'after' picture when it's finished, but that may be some months away now.
maria galvano
8 years ago
I agree classics and the carpet is stunning its all a matter of individual taste but WHAT A SHAME to loose original features sink is striking shape and fireplace is charming florals in carpet are beautiful someone with a love of that era would redecorate around these original features im thinking greys blacks pinks and soft greens making the back drop against them dramatic and modern and simple to marry against the colour and patterns of the original features. My parents home has fireplaces adams in bedrooms and clawed feet bathtub and when they had a grant to upgrade electrics and damp I had to fall out with the builders as they were taking original features out for themselves I got them brought right back. surely if you bought this style property it must have spoken to you mix old with new and have a beautiful different home that reflects you first of all never mind if others dont like it. But I do
maccoops thanked maria galvano
maccoops
Original Author
8 years ago
Thanks Maria, yes we love it, will probably give it a go keeping them - won't cost much that way and if it doesn't work, it's only paint we've wasted and we can start again. Thanks everyone.
maria galvano
8 years ago
your welcome from my experience you are always starting again with homes as styles and you change so you will have a head start. I'm always changing things with paint and reinventing rooms but over the years found that the classics especially if originals like yours will always stand the test of time and never go out of style but they dont have to look dated mix it up. if you tire of the carpet which I love think about making it into a huge rug bounded around the edge with what ever colour adorns your walls then would look stunning on a wood floor same with the sink could always be used in another room I would team it with black or even faux marble back drop oh endless fun and NOT AVAILABLE on the high street enjoy your home always
maccoops thanked maria galvano
PRO
Amanda Ralph
8 years ago
If you are keeping as a guest bedroom than a sink would be of benefit!
maccoops thanked Amanda Ralph
Josephine Geeson
8 years ago
Get rid of the sink but use the alcove - keep the fireplace, it's part of the house history and with imagination can be a feature, especially with those colours. You could hide the sink, build it into a frame flush with the level of the wall, cover with a lift up lid (taps tricky, must be able to solve that problem somehow) so when not in use becomes a surface for 'artistic things', hang an unusual mirror above - ta dah!
maccoops thanked Josephine Geeson
PRO
Mauro Perucchetti Ltd
8 years ago
What a great feature, to have a fireplace in your bathroom. It may be best to keep the fireplace and completely renovate the rest.

Have you thought of using Venetian plaster to give your space a facelift? This would give it a truly luxurious and fresh appearance.

Polished plaster can bring the best out of the fireplace and make a real statement to your project.
maccoops thanked Mauro Perucchetti Ltd
User
6 years ago
Don't loose it reuse it:) its unique who wants to be the same as everyone else ey!

you need to watch a wenz Anderson film to inspire you with this room. The Grand Budapest Hotel.

Goodluck !
maccoops thanked User
maccoops
Original Author
6 years ago

Finally got round to dealing with the bedroom - we kept the fireplace (with a bit of help from some plastikote, as directed by decorator) and lost the sink to be replaced by a cupboard with hanging rail (width ways) a small drawer and a shoe space! Sink available if anyone fancies a trip to Edinburgh! Not as warm as I had first envisaged, but I love it. Thanks to everyone for all the suggestions - all very helpful.
Jo Arnold
6 years ago
Gorgeous wallpaper.
maccoops thanked Jo Arnold
maccoops
Original Author
6 years ago
Thanks Jo - it’s Nina Campbell’s Swan Lake.
giovedesign
5 years ago
You can use a smaller sink, basin type, similar to a countryside one they used back in the days when they had no bathrooms. To give the feeling of "provence".