Pergola with retractable canopies vs. retractable awning

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

I'm torn between two shade solutions for my back deck: a retractable Solair awning and a pergola with retractable canopies on tracks. Help me decide! Here's my deck. Comments and suggestions welcome.

Retractable awning ($2500) - would be a lighter neutral brown

Pergola with retractable canopies ($5000) - would be a solid medium gray, not striped

Featured Answer

PRO

RetractableAwnings.com Inc.

6 years ago

last modified: 6 years ago

Your selection should be based on several important items:

1. Weather - Are you seeking sun protection only OR sun and light rain protection OR sun and heavy rain protection AND also how much wind will the product need to withstand when partially or fully extended?

Retractable pergola guide wire canopies such as our Perugia model https://www.retractableawnings.com/products/retractable-patio-and-deck-pergola-cover-systems/perugia/ are designed for sun only and not for rain. Designed to handle wind up to +-20 mph
Folding lateral arm awnings such as our Palermo Plus model https://www.retractableawnings.com/products/folding-lateral-arm-awnings/palermo-plus/are designed for sun and LIGHT rain. Designed to handle wind up to +-20 mph
Retractable pergola belt driven canopies such as our Salerno model https://www.retractableawnings.com/products/retractable-patio-and-deck-pergola-cover-systems/salerno/ are designed for sun, HEAVY rain and hail. Designed to handle wind up to +-63 mph and can be engineered to handle hurricane force winds up to 175mph
Rotating louver roof systems such as our Bioclimatique model https://www.retractableawnings.com/products/retractable-patio-and-deck-pergola-cover-systems/bioclimatique/ are designed for sun, HEAVY rain, hail, snow load and hurricane force winds. Engineering is based on zip or postal code/location

2. Aesthetics - Folding lateral arm awnings use spring loaded arms and therefore posts are not required. A pergola and louver roof system for the first, third and fourth options above require posts.

3. Outdoor Enclosed Area - Options one, three and four above allow one to have a completely enclosed entertainment area that can be air conditioned in the summer and heated in the winter.

4. Budget - Least expensive is a folding lateral arm awning, then a guide wire system and lastly the most expensive are belt driven pergola systems and rotating louver roof systems

I don't recommend the Lowes item mentioned above as the frame is steel and will rust eventually causing it to collapse. Fabric is a mesh that does not provide complete sun protection and the warranty is only 1 year (see the reviews on the Lowes website here: https://www.lowes.com/pd/Garden-Treasures-134-in-W-x-134-in-L-x-92-in-H-x-Matte-Black-Powder-Steel-Freestanding-Pergola-with-Canopy/50277121#609521+model+tp15-048c.

Please be sure to look for all aluminum non rusting frames with marine grade stainless steel components and a minimum 25 year frame and 8 year fabric warranty.

Hope that helps. Happy to answer more questions or address any and all comments

Comments (6)

PRO
Outback Construction
7 years ago
How is your area for wind? Sudden thunder storms? You have to be more careful with a retractable for the above weather situations than the pergola system if your pergola system is like the brand that we typically install (ShadeTree) Another company to consider is Craftbilt for a retractable or pergola system.

It really depends on if you want to lower your shade system every time you want to use the deck or spend a little extra and already have it in place.
H Cole thanked Outback Construction
H Cole
Original Author
7 years ago
We're in central NC so we get plenty of summer squalls and usually 1 or 2 serious thunderstorms a year. We would just plan to retract the awning anytime it wasn't in use. We'd probably also keep the pergola canopies retracted most of the time since we grow herbs on the deck. Thanks for the input!
Related Discussions
Ideas for a pergola
Q
Comments (8)
Nmelbourn, you could install an awning or some sail shades. A pergola is also great, even a gazebo. I also want something for our bi-folding doors, but just can't decide which is best. This is a small selection of the things I've been looking at: http://www.gardensite.co.uk/Garden_Structures/Easy_Fit_Wall_Mounted_Gazebo_Shade_3_metres.htm http://canopy.cunninghamcovers.co.uk/rectangular-garden-sail-canopy.php http://www.primrose-awnings.co.uk/?src=shop_department_m http://www.primrose.co.uk/sail-shades-c-85.html?src=shop_department_m_top_85
...See More
Our patio design
Q
Comments (2)
A pergola with a canopy sounds lovely! Instead of a bench maybe you could get an outdoor seating set with table? And it may take a little while to grow, so maybe not ideal as an immediate solution, but a "natural" pergola of climbing plants could be nice. Some photos for inspiration:
...See More
window advice on south facing extension...
Q
Comments (23)
Hi Tani Our garden is west facing & we have a window either side of the bifolds. We chose not to have roof openings to avoid extra heat from the sun. We are also considering adding an pergola/awning or something similar so that we can have the blinds open in summer without the hot sun streaming in. I am not a fan of hot weather (hence the integral blinds & air con) so avoid it as much as possible. I’m a bit confused what you mean about access to the traffic door...ours is by the kitchen end & is ideal. I’ve added a few pics so you can see our set up.
...See More
Need inspiration for dead outside space
Q
Comments (22)
Dare i say it....................probably.......................conservatories have had their day. They will add space, but you have to keep closing the doors and going in and out as they're not the warmest of places unless you splash out on glass roofs, or dismiss the roof design and go for a solid plastered ceiling etc. I don't think it's dead space, it could be a really nice patio right outside the conservatory, after all, you wouldn't constantly want to sit on the grass, you have a patio. It's also directly off the lounge or dining area.........perfect. I know that extensions are more expensive, however, they add room and light because you can take the internal doors away. If you need more space, i'd get rid of the the conservatories and have an extension across the back taking in both spaces. Putting up another conservatory is just adding another box, and it will darken the room to the right and hide the lovely casement doors. So, an extension right across the back taking the two areas in is far preferable. It adds permanent space usable all year round with no internal doors getting in the way.
...See More
monicamarie
7 years ago
One of the best things I have ever purchased is the Garden Treasurers pergola from Lowes, item #609521 model TP15-048C. You can easily move this canopy as the sun moves. Be sure to weave the canopy under the center cross bar and the wind is never a problem. It is extremely heavy but we still bolted it to the deck. For the price it is excellent!
PRO
Gerety Building and Restoration
7 years ago
I agree with the Pergola. Apart from being more practical & permanent, it looks nicer too.
PRO
Garden State Shade LLC
7 years ago
It looks like a pretty decent sized deck. If you prefer a retractable, it's going to have to be a decent projection (extension away from the house). I would make sure to choose a higher quality awning for the best and longest performance if you'll be using an awning to cover any more than 10'....with all due respect, a retractable awning seems to be a more practical solution. Open when you want shade/cover, no obstructions, and it's nearly invisible when it's closed.

I would suggest a stripe to mask any dirt or debris from what looks like a wooded area....Good luck!

Pergola with retractable canopies vs. retractable awning

RetractableAwnings.com Inc.

Comments (6)

Outback Construction

H Cole
Original Author

Related Discussions

monicamarie

Gerety Building and Restoration

Garden State Shade LLC

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Pergola with retractable canopies vs. retractable awning

RetractableAwnings.com Inc.

Comments (6)

Outback Construction

H ColeOriginal Author

Related Discussions

monicamarie

Gerety Building and Restoration

Garden State Shade LLC

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

H Cole
Original Author