help! double storey rear vs single storey rear+loft conversion?
Heather
6 years ago
Hello! We are still in the “pipe dream” phase of extending our house and would love some advice!
We currently have a small-ish 1950’s 3 bedroom detached house which had a small double storey rear extension put on in the 1980’s
Upstairs: 2 decent sized doubles, and one box room with irritating bulkhead over the stairs meaning you can’t even fit a single bed in there!)
1 gorgeous big bathroom
Downstairs: kitchen and separate lounge/diner (which is annoying when you have to walk through the lounge to get to the dining room from the kitchen!
Garden is fairly decent size but not enormous. Also have big ugly garage taking up half the rear garden - really useful for storage but our rear garden is south facing and all the sunlight seems to fall on the garage roof which then shades the whole garden
We would like (have separated into what we would definitely like and what we would like if possible)
Definitely want:
Open plan living/kitchen/dining
Utility room
Downstairs toilet
4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Garage GONE but still decent garden storage (our current garage is 16m2 internally but we would be fine with 8m2 of garden storage for all our garden stuff)
What we would like if possible:
1 bedroom to be master, with dressing area and ensuite
Other 3 bedrooms to comprise of box room and then 2 good sized doubles
We would love to still have a decent sized family bathroom with space for bath and separate shower as our current one is lovely and spacious (and I hate shower heads over baths)
Our current vague idea for downstairs is to do rear extension into the garden (would have to knock down garage to not make garden look minuscule), little side extension to create a bit more downstairs space, rebuild wall between living/dining areas, creating a snug at the front of the house then knock through rest of walls at the back to create living/dining/kitchen open plan (with the usual bifolding or sliding doors etc) plus utility and loo. (I assume there may still have to be some supporting columns that stay but will cross that bridge if we come to it)
For upstairs - we initially thought we would just do a loft conversion to create the extra bedroom and bathroom, however - due to the height of our roof we would HAVE to do a roof raise loft conversion (can’t lower the ceilings for the rooms below) which I gather would be ££££ and require planning permission (trying to get it all done on permitted development if poss)
An alternative that has been suggested (that would be cheaper) to us is to do the little side one storey extension plus a double storey rear extension and reconfigure the 1st floor to create the 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. We could technically do the rear within permitted development if it was 4m from the original rear wall on the ground floor and 3m on the 1st floor. However I am concerned that a) a double storey extension would look too imposing on a little garden and b) that would mean only 1metre of ‘roof space’ in the downstairs open plan area (had my heart set on roof lights, lots of light flooding in etc) - and the more internal part of the open plan would look dark and dingy.
Have attached the current plans showing dimensions etc - garden plan is horribly not to scale but the other ones are!
Would appreciate anyone’s views!
We currently have a small-ish 1950’s 3 bedroom detached house which had a small double storey rear extension put on in the 1980’s
Upstairs: 2 decent sized doubles, and one box room with irritating bulkhead over the stairs meaning you can’t even fit a single bed in there!)
1 gorgeous big bathroom
Downstairs: kitchen and separate lounge/diner (which is annoying when you have to walk through the lounge to get to the dining room from the kitchen!
Garden is fairly decent size but not enormous. Also have big ugly garage taking up half the rear garden - really useful for storage but our rear garden is south facing and all the sunlight seems to fall on the garage roof which then shades the whole garden
We would like (have separated into what we would definitely like and what we would like if possible)
Definitely want:
Open plan living/kitchen/dining
Utility room
Downstairs toilet
4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Garage GONE but still decent garden storage (our current garage is 16m2 internally but we would be fine with 8m2 of garden storage for all our garden stuff)
What we would like if possible:
1 bedroom to be master, with dressing area and ensuite
Other 3 bedrooms to comprise of box room and then 2 good sized doubles
We would love to still have a decent sized family bathroom with space for bath and separate shower as our current one is lovely and spacious (and I hate shower heads over baths)
Our current vague idea for downstairs is to do rear extension into the garden (would have to knock down garage to not make garden look minuscule), little side extension to create a bit more downstairs space, rebuild wall between living/dining areas, creating a snug at the front of the house then knock through rest of walls at the back to create living/dining/kitchen open plan (with the usual bifolding or sliding doors etc) plus utility and loo. (I assume there may still have to be some supporting columns that stay but will cross that bridge if we come to it)
For upstairs - we initially thought we would just do a loft conversion to create the extra bedroom and bathroom, however - due to the height of our roof we would HAVE to do a roof raise loft conversion (can’t lower the ceilings for the rooms below) which I gather would be ££££ and require planning permission (trying to get it all done on permitted development if poss)
An alternative that has been suggested (that would be cheaper) to us is to do the little side one storey extension plus a double storey rear extension and reconfigure the 1st floor to create the 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. We could technically do the rear within permitted development if it was 4m from the original rear wall on the ground floor and 3m on the 1st floor. However I am concerned that a) a double storey extension would look too imposing on a little garden and b) that would mean only 1metre of ‘roof space’ in the downstairs open plan area (had my heart set on roof lights, lots of light flooding in etc) - and the more internal part of the open plan would look dark and dingy.
Have attached the current plans showing dimensions etc - garden plan is horribly not to scale but the other ones are!
Would appreciate anyone’s views!
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (14)
Heather
6 years agoRelated Discussions
Hand drawn designs vs CAD designs...
Comments (104)Loved reading this discussion! I am an interior designer and have done my interior sketchign courses with BehindCanvas. The tutor is amazing and you can do the tutorials online in your own time and rewatch them. Highly recommend if you're interested in mastering sketching from zero!...See MoreWhich room should be which in a 5 storey Georgian terrace house?
Comments (30)I agree with Jonathan that the original proportions and symmetry will be important for keeping a wow factor. The house may originally have had two living spaces on the first floor so you could consider using one room there as a study. If you are a doggy family, a boot room in the basement might be useful if you can enter the house at that level. I would be inclined to have a separate laundry /ironing room on an upper floor if you don’t hang washing outside to dry. In a house this size you could consider a cinema/ computer games room in the basement if you would use it. Are you wine buffs - how about a wine cellar? Future owners can use the rooms for different things to you if they are generous enough sizes. It is important that you get to use as much of the house as suits your lifestyle as well as having a good number of bathrooms for whatever number of bedrooms you end up with. Do you entertain much? If so, would you use a formal dining room. Are you musical? Do either of you have hobbies like painting, crafting, woodwork? Do you collect things? If your living room is on a separate floor from the kitchen, how about having a tea/coffee making facility and a drinks fridge in a cupboard on that floor?...See MoreBathroom upstairs? Conservatory vs garden space?.
Comments (21)your house is almost exactly the same as my own house that I am currently doing work on. I would turn bedroom 3 into an en suite and a main bathroom - in your house you would have windows in the both rooms - I've attached my property floor plan to give you the idea. I too have a sun room attached to the back of my property which I was turning into a sitting room and putting a home office to the front of the property by partitioning the front room. I would definitely go for a utility room, they are a valuable luxury if you have the space, washing machine, mops, vacuum cleaners, coats - it's great to have somewhere to store all these things......See MoreTwo storey extension or loft?
Comments (3)Hi Majith, APT Renovation here, we are a design and build company that specialises in home extensions. May I ask where the property is located as we operate in South London and if you are located in our area of operation, looking for designers and builders for your extension we could offer you a free consultation and advise the best way to move forward with your build. If you would like to view our website and know more about what we do you can head to https://www.aptrenovation.co.uk/ or call us on 0207 223 6417. I trust you are staying safe in these trying times and hope to hear from you soon :) Kind regards, APT Renovation Ltd...See MoreHeather
6 years ago
A B
6 years agoHeather
6 years agoA B
6 years agoHeather
6 years ago
PROUrbanist Architecture
5 years agoHeather
5 years agoStacey Yeadon
5 years agoHeather
5 years agovanessajoyner
3 years ago
PRONest Estimating Ltd
3 years ago
PROAPT Renovation Limited
3 years ago
A B