Honey Oak Cabinet facelift before/after - do we paint!?

5 years ago

We took a stab at giving our new kitchen a facelift. Before picture is 1st and the photos below show the after-we have updated the countertops with quartz, new Kohler sink/faucet, backsplash, lighting, paint and hardware. The next step is updating the flooring, adding a pantry (and maybe a few cabinet doors) with glass doors to cut down on the oak overload. Finally, debating this-do we paint the cabinets? Note: we will be leaving the trim the honey oak, we have far too many windows and a slightly rustic home so white trim isn't in the cards. Thoughts?

Featured Answer

PRO

Lion Windows and Doors

5 years ago

I wouldn't paint the cabinets. They look great!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (35)

flopsycat1
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
Great improvemen! What are you planning for the floor? Agree with Lion....no paint for the cabinets.
Kayla S thanked flopsycat1
Related Discussions
Kitchen help - what can we do to make it look better?
Q
Comments (65)
Depending on how far you budget goes, I would look at adding traditional cornice and pelmet and replacing the plinth with a similar oyster colour. End panels for wall units could also be replaced / added. Some chessboard style tilling in 3 colours would also bring out the walls. It's hard to tell but is the oak surround also on the wall units? I haven't checked your location but this is something we can help with
...See More
What do you think I should do about this old dresser?
Q
Comments (25)
wow stellahome, what a grand house and entrance! I'm intrigued! Do you have many original features left in the house? servant bells maybe? :) Post some pictures for us! I am very familiar with lassco, in fact I currently live 5 mins away from there, and pop in often, they have many wonderful items which really enhance an old house. Took a couple of more pictures today of the dresser, as even though it looks very worn, look at the dovetail joint details! They certainly don't make them like this anymore (unless you pay a hefty price for it!)
...See More
Extending and can't match bricks.. shall we render the whole lot!??
Q
Comments (24)
If you can match the bricks do and then paint the window frames. Man About The House painted his (I think) UPVC windows a lovely sage green which would brighten the whole thing. He has posted some pics somewhere- it looks really lovely. Hopefully he can advise. I’ve totally copied his idea and the new windows are arriving in a couple of weeks. Can’t wait to see the difference it’ll make to our tired exterior!
...See More
Help on Painting Oak in-Frame Kitchen
Q
Comments (17)
Yes both, I’m doing a two tone kitchen. Craig and Rose tintern stone for top cabinets and finally decided on Valspar timber green which is green but almost black for lower cabinets. The Craig and Rose is good and has great sticking power but i noticed with some of the test pots and I’ll warn you it’s smelly...not like oil based paint fumes but like cheesy socks smelly. Glad I decided not to use it on the walls. And the Wilko clear varnish is the best I’ve used so far, comes in matt, satin and gloss, all water based, thin but I highly recommend. Not used them myself but Little Greene paints are supposed to be very good and I think they do oil based eggshell which should be very durable for kitchen cabinets. Tad expensive tho which is why I went for the emulsion and varnish method.
...See More
gm_tx
5 years ago
Nice updates! I vote for not painting the cabinets. Looks great, and they seem to go with the style of your home ... other trim work, etc.
Kayla S thanked gm_tx
mark_rachel
5 years ago
Very nice job! I would probably change the light over the sink to go with your other lights, but I would keep cabinets as is.
Kayla S thanked mark_rachel
PRO
Sina Sadeddin Architectural Design
5 years ago
I wouldn't paint the cabinets, but there are a few more smaller upgrades you can make. Get some newer cabinet hardware and a more simple light above the sink. Great job so far!
Kayla S thanked Sina Sadeddin Architectural Design
pdjh
5 years ago
Big improvement! Looks great! I like that the cabinets and your window trim match.
Kayla S thanked pdjh
Bri Bosh
5 years ago
Agree with others, leave the cabinets! Maybe a change to flooring is possible?
Kayla S thanked Bri Bosh
chloebud
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
Nice! Getting rid of that green paint makes the cabinets look less orange. Probably the lighting, too.
Kayla S thanked chloebud
colonel115
5 years ago
Agree. No to painting the cabinets. Changes look nice.
Kayla S thanked colonel115
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
5 years ago
Wow, I agree with everyone--the changes are very nice, and complement the oak cabinets. The kitchen has a sort of craftsman vibe now, and that would be negated by painting them. In addition, to paint now is doing things backwards.

I love the new pendant lights and the backsplash tile is very interesting.

What are you thinking of doing with the floor?
Kayla S thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
let1950
5 years ago
Backsplash tile is interesting; I like it. I also don’t have a problem with your floor tile. I think changing your cupboard hardware to something more substantial would be worth considering.
Kayla S thanked let1950
PRO
Beth H. :
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
i also concur w/everyone. looks great w/the wood cabs. Digging the craftsman look.

I like your backsplash. Hate your outlet covers. try and find something a bit better that blends w/that beautiful tile, especially that large one w/the two switches. (why wouldn't you have made that smaller or moved it up before tiling) ?
Kayla S thanked Beth H. :
Daniela Marino
5 years ago
I like it very much! And think your floor bends nicely now, is it in bad condition?
Kayla S thanked Daniela Marino
PRO
Pearl Remodeling
5 years ago
People often think that painting cabinets will make them look as good as new, as a professional I can tell you that unless your cabinets look horrible don't touch them. You did a great job!
Kayla S thanked Pearl Remodeling
User
5 years ago
Beautiful transformation! Cabinets look great as is!
Kayla S thanked User
MizLizzie
5 years ago
Nice. I agree that a more sleek looking light over the sink is about all that’s needed. I think the cabs are lovely. You did a great job.
Kayla S thanked MizLizzie
arcy_gw
5 years ago
WOW your pictures really are a testament to what color and light does to wood tones. Your cabinets sure look like you gave them a face lift i.e. cleaned even freshened the poly. As far as what else you could do, I would MAYBE, because I love the look, camouflage the soffit. With trim and veneer it is possible to hide the soffit and make it look like you have taller cabinets. Paint is for lower grade wood. Not something to do if you already have top of the line hardwood.
Kayla S thanked arcy_gw
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
5 years ago
Get rid of the incandecsent lighting and you might be surprised how much you like the cabinets as they are.
Kayla S thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
PRO
Coates Design Architecture + Interiors
5 years ago
That's a great update. I would not recommend painting the cabinets. I would save your budget for the floor.
Kayla S thanked Coates Design Architecture + Interiors
Cor
5 years ago
I agree with the above comment about the outlets. On the peninsula, try to find a wood one to blend in with the cabinets and try to find ones that blend with your backsplash better. New hardware on the cabinets would make a huge impact as well. I am pretty sure I don't like the flooring - it's a bit busy - competing against the grain in the oak and the backsplash. I think I'd learn towards something with a smaller pattern. Great job on the kitchen though. It's so satisfying to work with what you have.
Cheryl Hannebauer
5 years ago
change outlet covers & look for new hardware.... is the flooring staying?
Kayla S thanked Cheryl Hannebauer
ljoma
5 years ago
I love the cabinets the way they are, and the floor, while not exceptional, looks very nice with the rest of the room.
Kayla S thanked ljoma
arcy_gw
5 years ago
I looked and looked then re-read. The hardware has been updated. It goes very well with the lights and appliances!!!
Kayla S thanked arcy_gw
lightlystarched
5 years ago
The kitchen is beautiful! What are the backsplash tiles?
Kayla S thanked lightlystarched
Kayla S
Original Author
5 years ago
Thank you everyone!

This is the flooring we were considering. Feedback welcome! The photo of the sample is below but this is a link to the sample and is more accurate: https://coretecfloors.com/broad-spar-oak-vv024-00710/

Question about the hardware...it's hard to tell but we actually did update it. Originally, they were super ornate. We had a hard time finding the right size hardware to avoid having to drill new holes in the cabinet so we went w/ something very basic. Would love to see what type of hardware you would have gone with?

Our backsplash is Ann Sacks Savoy Field Tile.

Agree w/ the recommended changes about the light above the sink and updating light fixtures.
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
Re your flooring, I think I'd go with something a bit darker and/or warmer.

Maybe St. Andrews Oak?

https://coretecfloors.com/st-andrews-oak-vv024-00209/

Or Waterfront Oak?

https://coretecfloors.com/waterfront-oak-vv024-00703/

Or Kingswood Oak?

https://coretecfloors.com/kingswood-oak-vv024-00210/

Here are some photos of kitchens with stained wood cabinets and wood floors for you to consider:
Kitchen · More Info

Lakeville Residence · More Info

Craftsman Kitchen · More Info

2009 Southern Accents Showhome · More Info

Old World antique pine with custom tile backsplash · More Info

Or perhaps do something totally different, like a limestone or slate-look porcelain tile?
Traditional Kitchen · More Info

Tuscan Farmhouse · More Info

French Country Home · More Info

Quaktertown Kitchen · More Info

Hunter's Creek Remodeling · More Info
zealart
5 years ago
Looks fantastic. The choice of tile works so well in this space. Even the floor looks fine in the meantime.
JustDoIt
5 years ago
Look great. No paint.
ljptwt7
5 years ago
Nice job! If you think you have too much wood, and are adding wood floor, how about just changing the door? Is it a closet or pantry or an outside door? If a pantry, would a frosted glass door look nice? Just a suggestion because you mentioned adding glass doors.
PRO
OTM Designs & Remodeling Inc.
5 years ago
Looks great!
PRO
NHance Wood Refinishing
5 years ago
Going with a darker stain on the cabinets could be a good option if you would like to avoid painting but still update the look of an oak cabinet. I would just caution you from going too dark as it is a smaller kitchen and with the dark counter tops it may look too dark overall. Here are some colors that may be able to achieve a middle ground of darker, but not too dark.

https://i.pinimg.com/236x/c5/f8/67/c5f867e825cecb6aa1a026f41534c387--knotty-alder-drawers.jpg

http://wendyontheweb.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/stained-cabinets-colors-fabulous-1000-images-about-cabinet-stain-paint-hood-faux-patina-on-of-stained-cabinets-colors.jpg

https://www.diynetwork.com/how-to/maintenance-and-repair/cleaning/how-to-clean-wood-cabinets
PRO
Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center
5 years ago
Your kitchen looks amazing and your cabinets are gorgeous -- so versatile and timeless that they will be perfect regardless of the style changes you introduce in your home. Definitely no to painting them.
User
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
normally I love natural wood, but I might be the lone naysayer here -- I'd either paint or change out the doors. I'm not a fan of that style. (is that called raised panel?) it looks like 80s country to me. if it were my kitchen, I'd replace the doors with a slab or shaker style in a matching wood tone. if budget does not allow for that, then a medium or darker paint color could help make them a bit more current.

although that wood is pretty. perhaps you might wait until you do the new floor? that may be the final change this kitchen needs.

I LOVE your backsplash choice, by the way!
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
5 years ago
BF, yes the cabinets have a raised panel door style, which doesn't date from the 1980s, but the 1700s in America, the invention of which was superior to the common board-and-batten doors.

From the "Old House Online" website:

"Around 1700, the batten door was followed by the frame-and-panel door, more commonly called a raised-panel door. These are constructed of vertical wood stiles and horizontal rails that hold one or more “floating” recessed panels in place. Because pieces were designed to interlock without nails, the raised-panel door was less subject to seasonal expansion and contraction—a significant improvement over battened planks."

I think the plain raised panel door is a classic and looks beautiful in Kayla's kitchen!
PRO
Stecki Construction
5 years ago
The kitchen looks amazing with the cabinets as they are! I would not paint them. Love the kitchen! Thanks for sharing!

Honey Oak Cabinet facelift before/after - do we paint!?

Comments (35)

Related Discussions

Kayla SOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Kayla S
Original Author