Do I replace the shower pan if I am retiling a shower?

10 years ago

I just bought a 15 year old house and am redoing a bathroom. The contractor thinks we can tile over exisitng tile. Dont I have to replace the shower pan? I dont know if there were any leaks.

Featured Answer

PRO

Brickwood Builders, Inc.

10 years ago

I would never even consider putting new tile over existing tile. If you are in the midst of a remodel, now is the time to take it back to the studs and start again. It can be done now easily with a little more cost. If you don't do it right now and it fails in the future, you have an expensive mess on your hands and you can't match products.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

elivelund
10 years ago
I would.... I mean 15 years of water running I'm sure it would need a replacement - better than retiling and then finding out it needs replaced
Related Discussions
Bathroom upgrade -replace old or new tiles?
Q
Comments (3)
Even if you find the same tiles, I doubt they would be identical. I would probably splurge for new tile in the entire bathroom. If that is not an option, you could replace only the tile in the actual shower with an accent or something that really pops. Use that colour for the accents in your bathroom as well! If you decide on the latter, I would just be sure that the tiles you choose for the shower are a different shape from the ones in the remainder of the bathroom. That way it will really stand out. Here is some inspiration... https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/cool-gray-contemporary-bathroom-atlanta-phvw-vp~11724285 https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/bouldin-creek-residence-contemporary-bathroom-austin-phvw-vp~12952300 https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/flatiron-loft-renovation-eclectic-bathroom-new-york-phvw-vp~1279931 https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/apartamento-pequeno-e-colorido-em-sao-paulo-eclectic-bathroom-phvw-vp~34743681 https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/eclectic-bathroom-eclectic-bathroom-san-francisco-phvw-vp~20832973
...See More
Bathroom - separate shower and bath?
Q
Comments (18)
Hi, I'd definitely keep your feature bath. This can be painted in a nice Fired Earth Eggshell finish. I can't comment on your basin or wc, as I can't see them and have no idea what condition they are in? I'd tile the floor, shower areas and window reveals. I'd suggest upstands (skirting tiles) around the rest of the bathroom, then you can add some nice colour to your bathroom your painted bath will be a lovely feature. Have a look at some of my photosets which may give you some inspiration. Having said all this, I think your budget is unrealistic. The most important component in your new bathroom is the person who undertakes the work and this will cost you money. Good luck with your project. Jeremy
...See More
Walk in shower Dilemma advice appreciated
Q
Comments (15)
Chris, We have the same shower tray as you (but in the 150cm format) and also exactly the same issue. I think it's a design fault as the tray is too shallow and the ridge round the edge does not contain the water. Our highly untechnical solution has been to buy shower mats which are exactly 80cm wide (from Christy on their website) and then to accept that they will get soaked and to dry them on the heated towel rail. Sorry if this is not the most sophisticated solution but it works for us. Good luck
...See More
replacing tiles in shower area
Q
Comments (8)
I never thought about changing the tiles behind the sink area to start in a corner- that’s a good idea! I am looking to replace the sink as well with a wall hung vanity unit to give more storage. I’ve realised that the new shower will extend forward a couple of centimetres from the existing one so hopefully it might fall on the ‘join’ line if we decide to retile just that area. Thanks for the tip re replacing all the grout
...See More
sandra
10 years ago
My tiled shower pan in my 54 yr old house is leaking. Can I put an insert shower over my tile?
PRO
Dytecture
10 years ago
It's better to do it 'right' the first time to minimize problems later.
dcconstruct
10 years ago
No, if it is the original pan it is made of lead and must be replaced entirely down to studs. Are you certain it is not the existing 54 year old tile that has lost its glazed finish? If so, it could be the walls that are absorbing water and taking the path of least resistance.
dcconstruct
10 years ago
My response was for Sandra
sandra
10 years ago
I have a 1960s Florida house with plastered walls. The water has shown up on the newer base boards and no marks on the plaster. Does that sound like the leak is coming from the pan or walls?
dcconstruct
10 years ago
Sandra,
Is the house a slab on grade? If so, it could be the pan. Is the shower valve on the same side as the leak?
sandra
10 years ago
The house is on a slab and the leak is coming out on all 3 walls that back onto the shower.
PRO
By Any Design Ltd.
10 years ago
Sounds like a liner failure. Time to do a "Do Over" - You may be able to salvage the original pre-slope layer if this was well done.

However you said moisture loss on three walls and that would lead me to think the pre-slope is not there to begin with.
lewmett
10 years ago
Anybody replacing tile in their shower should take it down to the subfloor and at least the dry wall, better to the studs. While your at it replace the shower valve. An acrilyc base is the easiest to install. Can be a DYI project, but you need to know what your doing.
PRO
Better Living Design (BLD)
9 years ago
I agree that taking out old (even if not leaking) tile or pans back to the studs and flooring is the best plan. Then install all new, modern, plumbing, fixtures, etc. No way to cheap out on that without risking problems.

Do I replace the shower pan if I am retiling a shower?

Brickwood Builders, Inc.

Comments (12)

elivelund

Related Discussions

sandra

Dytecture

dcconstruct

dcconstruct

sandra

dcconstruct

sandra

By Any Design Ltd.

lewmett

Better Living Design (BLD)

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US