I am wondering whether to remove tired upstairs carpets and continue engineered wood flooring through out all 3 floors and add rugs OR go for a "natural" floor covering like sisal? I would welcome opinions re: Noise, cost, longevity etc....
Sisal is hideously impratical regarding spills, essentially it can't be cleaned, it's also quite rough but does have a very special look to it. Many of the Sisal manufacturers are bringing out 'faux sisal' which mimics the real thing but is easy clean. Neither will be as warm or cosy as regular carpeting. Engineered Wood can fell quite harsh in upstairs areas and will inevitably be noisy and colder too than carpeting.
I have a wool stair carpet by Crucial Trading which has a rough texture like sisal but it’s cosy, warm and easy to clean. Not a cheap option but they have a fab range of carpets. Sisal is very difficult to clean as it’s lumpy and bumpy and dirt gets ingrained. I had a sisal rug but got rid of it as it’s very difficult to hoover too.
Many people have underfloor heating installed when fitting new floors. Personally I don't have a UFH system in my home as I think the running costs can be high, but many people would disagree with me as it does feel nice underfoot. In our upstairs rooms I have carpet rugs on top of our engineered oak that I had whipped to the perfect size for our bedrooms. Ask your local carpet shop for off-cuts in a colour of your choice. I got mine done for a fraction of the cost of a quailty shop bought rug and it's custom sized to my rooms.
Whilst Engineered or Solid Wood can feel slightly colder in the winter it's certainly not colder than LVT or Laminates or Tiles. Long term Engineered wood in my view would be the best option especially as the cost compared to a decent carpet isn't as much as it used to be. Some wood options are cheaper than carpet these days. I would also recommend using an acoustic underlay prior to fitting the new floor.
Alex Burnett
Sonia
Related Discussions
Decisions decisions - go dark or not?
Q
1st Floor Layout and Landing
Q
Decision for floor tiles
Q
Tiles and flooring decisions for Victorian bathroom
Q
Woodfloors4u