POLL: Open-plan or closed layout?

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

Open-plan layouts are very, very popular, and for good reason. They're a great way to maximise space, whether you have a big or a small home.

However, tearing down walls can be expensive and some homeowners prefer to leave the smells and mess behind in the kitchen, so a closed layout is a better option for them.

What do you prefer - open or closed layouts?

Open-plan

Closed

Other - tell us below!

Featured Answer

PRO

Amber Jeavons Ltd

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

I like both but it entirely depends on the architecture of the build.. Spatially, feasibly as it's not right for all styles... and whether the client wants it. Then the other cruncher.... Financially doable on the given budget..... : ))

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (22)

User
8 years ago
I agree, I like both too. If the kitchen is large enough then keep it enclosed. However, if you are battling with space, then certainly open it up.
Related Discussions
POLL: Yay or nay - open plan kitchens?
Q
Comments (206)
We are often approached by clients who are creating an open plan kitchen, dining and living area. To overcome some of the issues we make cabinetry which can hide away the usual clutter found in a busy kitchen. Bi-fold and pocketing doors are great in this instance as ovens and even sinks can be hidden away, making the cabinetry seem more like a piece of furniture than a kitchen. Our clients love being able to change the look of a space in an instance! It is crucial to make sure you choose your appliances carefully, i.e. a quiet dishwasher and a good extractor are of huge benefit here. As long as the space is thoughtfully planned there is no reason that it shouldn't work functional and aesthetically.
...See More
POLL: Open plan bathrooms - yay or nay?
Q
Comments (18)
Hello Bagnodesign, I rather think that designing with "trend" in mind would be fleeting and offer the idea of continual change. I rather prefer the idea of designing with longevity in mind.. It's less about being fashionable but more about what is right for the space and clients needs, likes, budget and so forth.. I think this is not a symbiotic relationship between shower and closet and poses no real advantage as you can easily create a luxurious bathroom or shower room with a nearby closet area that is completely separate and moisture free.. It is though, entirely a matter of personal taste, but perhaps all that is needed is a degree of further separation which houses the shower and thus the resulting moisture is contained.. : ))
...See More
Open plan family kitchen layout.
Q
Comments (14)
oooh study idea sound good too.. I sketched that on the plans originally but didnt know how it would work with hip roof but now we are having a flat roof at the back it will be fine! Just sent the planning application off so will have to see what happens, hope it wont cost to much if we have to change it a little. Thanks for all your help every one, I have 3 or 4 contenders now so I think the next step will be to get quotes from builders to see which is most cost effective for our budget!
...See More
1930’s semi - best open plan layout for kitchen/diner or all open?
Q
Comments (24)
I’m struggling to find a way to have a kitchen/island (really would like an island to have useable counterspace), generous dining table (seating for at least 6 people) and a sitting area in the same room if we don’t open up the wall between the current front and back living rooms. Would it make more sense to have part of the garage incorporated into the kitchen? There is a slight difference in floor level though between the garage and kitchen (Step down into the garage). Or block up the current kitchen door and have the access to a dining/kitchen through the current back living room space and then somehow fit in a dining table and seating area?
...See More
PRO
Louise Richardson-Vine
8 years ago
I've lived with both and have to say I prefer open plan. This might be because I've lived with two enclosed galley kitchens where it's been a struggle for two people to be cooking/washing up etc. at the same time and is unsociable when you have guests over. I also like that with open plan the fridge is never too far from the sofa...
SSR
8 years ago
Open plan is definitely more visually appealing but it can be a problem when cooking. You might not be able to get the smell out of the cloth furniture or carpet.
rmmul
8 years ago
With 2 teenage sons a fully open ground floor wouldn't work for us. So while I like the look of open plan sometimes it can more practical to have separate living areas. We do have an open kitchen dining living area which is great for entertaining and having the whole family in but they still each have their own areas (albeit compact!) to retreat to. 2 of our other rooms have double doors which can be opened out to create nearly a fully open ground floor though- maybe the best of both worlds!!
Olena Tkach
8 years ago
A separate kitchen is a must for our family because I often cook when everyone is sleeping, so I need closed doors in order to be able to use blenders and mixers and even chop products with a knife.

Another must-have is a separate kids room as it allows both do not disturb a kid when it's sleeping and avoid Lego blocks and RainbowLoom bands all over the house.

Everything else (dinning, watching movies, hobbies, resting and chatting) may be incorporated into one open layout to allow easier communications between family members.
User
8 years ago
It depends on how big your kitchen is. I had a galley kitchen and had I not been able to afford an extension I would definitely have had to have knocked a wall down to prevent my blood pressure from becoming fatal! So as long as rooms are big enough I prefer closed rooms. How on earth do you get away from the 'maddening' crowds otherwise!
biscuitaandcrumbs
8 years ago
I've always had a separate kitchen area, of which I prefer, but at the same time open plan is lovely if you have a lot of space.
Juliet Docherty
8 years ago
Loved open plan until I have had to endure 5000 episodes of Spongebob whilst trying to enjoy a quiet coffee in the kitchen.....
Jackie Hales
8 years ago
Ideally both, big kitchen, diner and family space for sharing with another separate dining & lounge. Well I can but dream
margretg2
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
One of the arguments for open plan is that it's more visually appealing and makes the space look larger. I agree that it can look visually appealing in carefully-wrought design photos where everything is perfect. But if it's not perfect? If there are dirty cups on a counter (come on, we all produce those) a mess of toys on the floor, the remains of someone's artistic/craft effort on a table instead of a tastefully arranged vase and two books, it's a different story. And does it really make the space look larger? Ask any trained gardener which looks bigger - an open space or a sequence of rooms (try visiting the famous Hidcote - http://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/hidcote/ ) and the answer will always be that a space looks larger when the eye cannot see everything at once. Smaller rooms with mirrors can look double their size.
Tina
8 years ago
I live in a traditional Victorian terraced house which had the hall/living room/dining room knocked through by a previous owner. This aspect is open plan and is bright, large and very usable for a young family. However, the kitchen is the standard small but perfectly formed galley. This combination offers the best of both worlds - I can keep my on the children and chat with visitors in the living room or at the dining table while cooking but can close the door to block food smells and visible mess. Perfect :-)
Jan Johnson
8 years ago
Had bad experience with open plan when family was young. The noise from the kitchen interferred with TV watching and yes the cooking fumes went throughout the house.
margretg2
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Jan Johnson, I agree. Cooking fumes are always going to be a problem in open-plan living. Extractor fans get fancier but even some experts agree they're not that efficient. And even if they are, they're usually placed over the hob. What about the oven? Most ovens - Agas are an exception - blow the smells straight back into the kitchen. Very nice if you're baking bread or cakes; not so good for roast meat or anything containing onions.

Like most things in interior design (flush-faced doors, blocked off Victorian fireplaces, fake-stone chimney breasts, feature walls) open-plan is a fashion. When it falls out of favour, we'll all be putting back the stud walls the previous owners demolished.
Karin Madgwick
8 years ago
In Australia open plan is the way to go, with this space then opening out onto a covered alfresco
PRO
EZ-PLANS
8 years ago
Open plan is the way forward !!
PRO
Redwood Home Improvements Ltd
8 years ago
Open plan creates a much better living space
Wendy White
8 years ago
Open plan ensures that you use ALL your space... do you have a room that doesn't get used because it feels shut off from the rest of the house?... solution...open plan living. (excluding bathrooms of course!).
PRO
Coats Architecture
8 years ago
Open plan works best if the space is flexible and environment controlled to suit user
PRO
The Inclusive Home
8 years ago
I generally prefer open plan from a flexibility and accessibility point of view, but it is nice sometimes to zone or separate some areas depending on the home and how you like to use it
PRO
Amber Building (NW)Ltd
8 years ago
Open plan mordern way of living
PRO
Avalon Antique Fireplaces
8 years ago
open plan trust me !

POLL: Open-plan or closed layout?

Amber Jeavons Ltd

Comments (22)

User

Related Discussions

Louise Richardson-Vine

SSR

rmmul

Olena Tkach

User

biscuitaandcrumbs

Juliet Docherty

Jackie Hales

margretg2

Tina

Jan Johnson

margretg2

Karin Madgwick

EZ-PLANS

Redwood Home Improvements Ltd

Wendy White

Coats Architecture

The Inclusive Home

Amber Building (NW)Ltd

Avalon Antique Fireplaces

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US