Fireplace dilemma

6 years ago

last modified: 6 years ago

My chimney is about 48 years old. I had it rebuilt from the roof up about 10 years ago. Now both new and old bricks are deteriorating. Additionally, we had a "thermal event" which caused the clay flue tiles to crack. I want to replace the entire chimney. Insurance adjuster says they will probably pay for just putting a stainless steel flue down the chimney.

Is brick or stone more likely to hold up to Chicago weather?

Are there any other options? The rest of the house is Hardie cement board. If I can use Hardie board I'd like to build in a little storage area for gardening tools.

Also thinking of upgrading to a heat radiating FP. Is it worth the extra cost? We have a single story home.

Thanks for your help!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

Matthew
6 years ago
How are new bricks deteriorating if they are only 10 years old? Or is it more specifically the mortar? Rebuilding a whole chimney will be $$$$. Has a mason made an assessment on what can be done.
PRO
Rockford Chimney Supply
6 years ago
Hello Mitchpat,

There are other alternatives to brick chimneys. If the brick chimney is eliminated above the roof, you can transition to a class A chimney pipe by using a transition plate, Rock-Vent class A chimney pipe, and chimney cap.
Related Discussions
Art Deco fireplace dilemma
Q
Comments (37)
The problem is the stark cold white walls against the soft warm browns of the fireplace. I don't recommend going all beige but try colours from the same warm spectrum as the fireplace and I think you'll find it looks more natural in the space. Also, the round candles don't work with the squares and oblongs of the fireplace; find other accessories that enhance rather than scream at the shapes and colours and that could make a huge difference. So could a mirror or picture above it - it would shift the focus so the fireplace doesn't dominate. Work with it, not against, then judge it. These fireplaces are handsome; trying to pretty them doesn't work.
...See More
Fireplace dilemma
Q
Comments (10)
Are the recesses the same size? Would the piano fit on the right and the lower chest on the left? The alcoves are slightly off balance due to the difference in size of the objects in them. The smaller chest I think is too low and would be better swapped for a larger more commanding Wooden chest of a similar bulk to the piano. Or something like this to brighten the corner and tone in with the lovely mustard armchair at the other end. Plus I'd swap the silvery edged mirror with chunky wood to tie in with the sofas as it currently doesn't match anything. This one has a shelf on it to make up for the lack of a mantel. Lastly i'd pull the sofa ends round a little to face the Fireplace and the piano as currently it's a bit of a walk through. Maybe separate the two armchairs between doors, put the leather one there. Move the dogtooth one next to the new mustard sideboard in the alcove and bring the dogtooth one further in to the room to counteract the furniture all lining the walls.
...See More
Exposed fireplace dilemma
Q
Comments (3)
As Sonia says, the brick arches were always hidden. I’m in a Victorian terrace and our fireplaces had been boarded up. When we opened them up, we initially kept the arches and plastered around them (no fire surround) - this was mainly due to cost at the time! I’ve since installed a fire surround over one of them. I couldn’t find a perfect fit, so having priced up all my options, I ended up getting a bespoke stone surround made to measure. It worked out cheaper than buying off the shelf and making fit. I guess you need to decide what you like and what style you are aiming for. It’s your house so you can do what you like! Keeping the arches and plastering around them is still popular and can look lovely. Installing a fire surround can also look lovely!
...See More
Fireplace Dilemma
Q
Comments (3)
We had several in our 1930s house and I really didn’t like them. My husband removed them all and the living room one we replaced with something more attractive. They are like marmite - you either love them or hate them!
...See More
graywings123
6 years ago
You can have a cast-in-place masonry liner poured inside your chimney. I had it done on a 120 year old chimney.

Cast in place flue liner

Fireplace dilemma

Comments (3)

Matthew

Rockford Chimney Supply

Related Discussions

graywings123

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US