Feedback on Floor Plan

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

Hi Houzz People

First time builders would like to request some suggestions/feedback on floor plan. Any comments on improvements or modifications are welcome.

Featured Answer

desireebarnes1

7 years ago

Hi guys
Mayb look in some display homes and get a feel of how big 3.4 X 3metre rooms are to realise how small they are! U have so many little boxy rooms, I would make the media
Room bedroom 4 and the join your games
Room and bedroom 4 together to make one
V large media/games room so u have space
To really feel u can relax and not feel confined, my media room now is your size and we hate it, it's like a prison! So
We now have to take walks out! More rooms
Are not the be all and end all, open space and comfort is!
Your main bathroom would b much bigger
If toilet was not in its own room too! But inside bathroom!
Just saying!
Good luck

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (28)

PRO
MB Design & Drafting
8 years ago
Seems quite ok. Only thing I don't like is the sink position as I would have it on the island bench. Aside from that its quite reasonable without knowing the site, etc..
PRO
Bubbles Bathrooms
7 years ago
The shower should not be beside the entry door - every body who uses the bathroom after someone has used the shower will trac water through the house
Related Discussions
3D plan of loft floor plans?
Q
Comments (8)
Try http://www.sketchup.com/ - it's incredibly simple to use and there's a community library of common furniture from IKEA et al. All for free!
...See More
Open plan or semi open plan? Floor plan / furniture layout help please
Q
Comments (5)
Hi all, Thank you for your comments; I appreciate them! Natasha - the units you have suggested are very much what I had in mind. We will have a shaker kitchen and the media unit would also be shaker style and would have 4-6 cupboards with the TV in the middle with book shelves either side. Part of the reason we kept a partial wall was to make the space more usable. I can’t envision how the fully open plan room will be able to meet all our needs, but I am open to ideas! I feel that open plan would be more impressive, but potentially less usable. With regards to the doors. I do plan to reverse the doors both into the kitchen and family room part, but couldn’t work out how to do it on the app I used for the floor plan. It is a 1920s house and we have the original doors which we are planning to keep. We are also keeping a lot of floor space as when the table is not extended, we still have young children with lots of Lego and trains etc. I plan for these to be hidden in the cupboards at bedtime. J - we haven’t installed the kitchen but we have ordered it and paid a big deposit. Some of the units are bespoke/irregular sizes and I don’t think we would be willing to change this. I have attached a photo of our rendered kitchen plan. Thanks again for your comments. It is good to have other people’s opinions and ideas.
...See More
Feedback on this renovation plan - room sizes?
Q
Comments (4)
Ditto re very good sized bedrooms. The only thing I would consider is if you could squeeze in another separate shower or at least a wc up there if you have 3 doubles sharing one bathroom? I guess it depends on how many rooms are permanently filled and also if you have any downstairs facilities
...See More
Kitchen Layout - feedback on this plan please!
Q
Comments (7)
Personally I don’t like this plan at all. I think the ovens are too far from the hob, the island is undersized and definitely won’t fit 4 stools, I don’t like island stools lined in a row, and I think the kitchen designer has tried so hard to fit in a pantry there is a massive wasted space in front of it. The dishwasher position is bad because you will always be on the wrong side of it when unloading and since there is space you should have a bigger sink rather than a 340/180 sink where neither bowl is very big. And although I can see other commentators thoughts on the practicality of a corner unit I don’t like to see a hotch potch of different door sizes and drawers. This is what I would do
...See More
PRO
Studio Urbo
7 years ago
It is hard to comment without knowing your brief. The kitchen looks too small proportionally to the house, and it is on the way to the living area. To achieve better bathroom design you may combine the bathroom and the powder room and put an extra toilet pan into the laundry. Access to the bathroom facilities from bedroom two is inconvenient and throughout the living area. Too many doors in the corridor between bedroom three and four. Hope this helps.
PRO
Reclaim your space
7 years ago
I like the layout, I'd like to live there, especially the master bedroom :)

I agree with Studio Urbo though, the toilet is quite a distance from Bed2 and the media room. Hard to make suggestions without knowing the brief, but I'd probably look to add in an additional powder room. Not sure if it can go somewhere above the garage, or maybe compromise on the WIP.
PRO
Envirotecture
7 years ago
Where about in Aust are you?
Vasu Patel
Original Author
7 years ago
Thanks Studio Urbo, MB Design & Drafting, & sgdeitz for your feedback. Bedroom 2 will be used as nursery for few years and then converted to Study or something later on. We are at maximum now for build area limitations and therefore reconfiguring is only option. Still working on increasing kitchen width & making bathroom bit larger. Any suggestions??
Vasu Patel
Original Author
7 years ago
Envirotecture, South of Sydney.
clikmania
7 years ago
Hi Vasil - very exciting building your own home but it seems massive to me - big house can mean big bills and more time cleaning!! Have you considered multi-functional spaces too? At the entrance-there is a long corridor which may feel oppressive - can you add height or roof lights there? Just a thought :)
Bryan Lip
7 years ago
Accessibility to the bathroom for Bed 2 seems a little difficult?
Najeebah
7 years ago
I would:
alter the master bathroom if possible, to have a flush wall on the right of the house
find a way to incorporate another/ a larger window there as well
change the door location of the closet to one of the ends, not centered on the wall, so that the door opens against the wall and does not block storage

what will the 'games room' be used for? would it be possible to incorporate it into the living room or bedroom 2, and thus have a greater living-dining area
Najeebah
7 years ago
also consider bringing the short wall with the entrance door forward, in line with the garage wall, so its not as tucked away
Vasu Patel thanked Najeebah
PRO
Envirotecture
7 years ago
Depending on far south...

Assumption, you have a boundary close to the NE edge of the house and a neighbour just (~2m) beyond. If so then most of your northeast windows will not get great sun for most of the day in winter (hard to be precise here) therefore the recessed corner is key to getting winter sun (free heating). If the alfresco roof is a fixed roof then this will not work and you will be very reliant on mechanical heating.

Solution; retractable shading device of some sort over ALF.

Big picture suggestion: you have 3 living areas in the house, why not reduce to two, pull back part of the NE wall to give genuine northern sun capture and have a house with no bills.

As URBO said at the start. It's very hard to give great advice without knowing the full story.

Good luck.
Vasu Patel thanked Envirotecture
ibissue
7 years ago
I'd put the master bed against a different wall. Our bed backs onto the kitchen as in your design and it can be noisy if someone is trying to sleep in!
kubbyfish
7 years ago
I would leave the kitchen sink where it is. The first home I built had an island bench with a sink and it got in the way while entertaining ( dishes) and can get quite messy while doing the dishes. The next house I built also had an island bench with sink but I altered the design so that the sink was against the wall like yours. It works much better and the island bench provides clutter free prepping space. Make sure you put power points in the island bench.
PRO
Reclaim your space
7 years ago
I think if it was me, I'd forego the Media room. make that Bed1, with the WIR & ensuite moved up a bit. Then behind them have the prayer room and WIP, backing onto the kitchen. This means you could make Bed2 and 3 longer, or put in a powder room or small laundry, and in turn make your main bathroom bigger.
olldroo
7 years ago
Reverse your master bedroom so the ensuite adjoins the kitchen and keep plumbing together. Saves on water usage and is more economical for hot water.
User
7 years ago
Hi. I vote for keeping your current kitchen layout! My last house I had sink in island - this time, my new kitchen is same layout as yours. I want to keep my island completely plain - great for prep area, eating, serving area for buffets and moves dirty dishes to a less obvious area!

Only addition I would suggest - add a skylight to your WIrobe for natural light. Good luck!
Paul Brewster
7 years ago
Unfortunately, most people start with a plan and then fit it on to a block of land. In my opinion, you need to look at your block of land and the surroundings first - neighbouring houses, outlook, any views to be taken advantage of, slope of the land etc etc. Then consider the orientation of the house. You have appropriately placed living areas on the North side so as to take advantage of northerly sunlight - great. But that means all the bedrooms have a mostly Southerly aspect which is usually damp and receives little if any sunlight. You haven't provided any information regarding the size of the block or the siting of the residence on the block, so I can't really comment on whether any alternatives are available. But please, please, think about the house and garden as an overall project and create something special bringing all aspects together.
kooky_karen
7 years ago
I agree with others about keeping kitchen sink where it is. So much better to have bench to work on. If you want the kitchen bigger - push the island bench out to the edge of the window and continue the bench with the sink in it to the window also.

The suggestion to flip the ensuite and master bedroom is a good one.

I would make the powder room smaller and have the laundry (flip it), toilet and bathroom in a U shaped corridor. That way the shower would not be right next to the door. (I have this set up and still have room for a hand basin in the toilet.) Also, although the bathroom is not overly large, a large clear glass window (almost to the height of the bath) will make the room look larger. (Again, I have this set up - with an 1800mm bath that is the width of the room so it is not large.)

The hinged door in WIR, I would change to a cavity door. That way you don't have to close the door behind you to find the items hanging behind it.

I hope this gives you some ideas.
Najeebah
7 years ago
the sink location is very much a personal preference, so go with what suits you. I do agree with the posters who mentioned the need for skylights (closet, prayer room, passage) as well as the need to build your plan around your plot.
longbeachgrannyflat
7 years ago
Move the ensuite and air to against the kitchen wall. I would also move the shower, basin and bath taps to the wall closet to the toilet. With the plumbing savings, I would insulate more, and move the AV unit away from the bedrooms to against the garage wall to reduce noise. ( actually I would figure out where the prevailing breezes come from and have cross ventilation and a solenoid operated solar roof vent to keep the heat in the roof cavity down in summer, so that you don't need the air con.
ramcub
7 years ago
If you don't mind an internal toilet with exhaust fan, flip:
1. Ensuite toilet/shower to the internal wall against the walk in robe; and
2. Vanity against the external wall.

Thus a large central mirror above the vanity can be side-lit from both sides with small corner windows for a bit of wow and significantly more natural light.

I also vote to flip the ensuite/robe with the master:
1. Shorter hot water runs with ensuite near the kitchen;
2. Quieter master suite;
3. More secluded master suite access from the main entry.
john9539
7 years ago
The design is fine for family living with bedrooms on the south and living rooms facing north. The kitchen design is good however I have a problem with the dining/family and games room layout and room sizes. My suggestion is to move the alfresco down to where the dining area is and locate the dining where the family area is. The games room can then be extended into where the alfresco area was previously. In other words locate the alfresco centrally so that the kitchen, dining and games room all look into this area. Hope this makes sense
Najeebah
7 years ago
any updates, vasil?
Vasu Patel
Original Author
7 years ago
Najeebah still work in progress. Thanks all for lovely suggestions. Here's some changes that we are thinking.

- making it a sound proof wall between Master Bed & Kitchen wall as entry to Master bed has to be that way because Bed2 is going to be used as Nursery. WIR will have a sliding door instead of Hinged

- Trying to swap master Ensuite's vanity with Shower and WC

- Making family bathroom larger (not sure which way though as I really want to keep WC separate).

- Skylights definitely on the agenda (cost depended)

- Partition wall for games room which will only be used for kids to play and can be utilised as extra covered area during family barbeques.

- Envirotecture , we are putting up a raked ceiling in kitchen/family as it is sloping slightly downwards towards our block so to have extra light in.

Not saying have ignored other suggestions and will work on things on priority basis and as Beekon Pty Ltd suggested we have taken into consideration this as overall project and want to keep things that will suit our family for many years to come.
olldroo
7 years ago
Vasil - as much as sliding doors are great space savers, they can become very noisy over time, especially noticeable in bedrooms. Maybe think about keeping the WIR door as a swing but swinging into the bedroom. It will be kept closed when not in use, so it won't be a nuisance, but will give you access to all the wardrobe. My grands all have WIR in their bedrooms with doors swinging outwards and they work very well.

I can understand you wanting to have your bedroom door as close as possible to the entrance to the nursery, but mirror reversing your master bedroom won't move the door that much and in fact you will find that having doorways a little off-centre to each other is very helpful for manoeuvring large items of furniture in and out of rooms.
donnawildy
7 years ago
I need a magnifying glass to see this plan.

Feedback on Floor Plan

desireebarnes1

Comments (28)

MB Design & Drafting

Bubbles Bathrooms

Related Discussions

Studio Urbo

Reclaim your space

Envirotecture

Vasu Patel
Original Author

Vasu Patel
Original Author

clikmania

Bryan Lip

Najeebah

Najeebah

Envirotecture

ibissue

kubbyfish

Reclaim your space

olldroo

User

Paul Brewster

kooky_karen

Najeebah

longbeachgrannyflat

ramcub

john9539

Najeebah

Vasu Patel
Original Author

olldroo

donnawildy

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Feedback on Floor Plan

Comments (28)

Related Discussions

Vasu PatelOriginal Author

Vasu PatelOriginal Author

Vasu PatelOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Vasu Patel
Original Author

Vasu Patel
Original Author

Vasu Patel
Original Author