Bigger bathroom v 4th bedroom?

7 years ago

Hi everyone.

We have plans done for a double storey extension to the side of our 1930s semi. As you will see from the design, the first floor will be reconfigured to have 3 decent sized double bedrooms with master suite at the back of the house with dressing area leading into en-suite.

However, on reflection, we have decided to incorporate a 4th bedroom instead of the luxury of en-suite - mainly for resale value. So we have two options:
1. Use the full area currently designed for dressing area and en-suite for a decent sized single room.
2. Use the dressing area only to create a box bedroom and use the majority of en-suite space to make the family bathroom bigger.

So it essentially comes down to what is more important - a bigger family bathroom or bigger 4th bedroom?

Any thoughts welcomed!

Thanks
Chris

Featured Answer

Danielle Garber

7 years ago

If you're thinking of resale value and the build cost is £100k - the figures the local agent has given you don't really stack up in terms of making a profit, it sounds like you'd just about break even so unless you're doing it to live in it for a while, I'd probably rethink whether that's an investment you want to make?

Can you trim anything off the build cost, are there any areas you could save on?

I'd definitely do some more local market research to see how much similar houses are going for in the area, you don't want to end up needing to push the ceiling price for a 3 bed to make your money back or struggling to sell a bottom-heavy 4 bed with only 1 bathroom as you'll be limiting your market for buyers.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

Irene Spinks
7 years ago
A bigger or second bathroom would be my choice. In a 4 bedroom house there could be too many people all needing to use the one bathroom at the same time. We have just renovated a 4 bedroom house (2 doubles 2 singles) and have turned one of the singles into our en suite, no more queueing for the loo in the morning bliss!
A B
7 years ago
I would keep it exactly as you plan unless you need a 4th bedroom. When you come to sell you could always take out ensuite to create 4th bedroom if agents think that would make you more (I doubt it unless you could have a second bathroom downstairs?)
Related Discussions
Houzz Live Chat - Tips for dressing your windows, September 4th, 3pm
Q
Comments (81)
Hiya Jill, thanks for sending those images over. In response to your first question about your bedroom, I can think of a couple of solutions that may work. The first is the same solution as my previous French window answer to @montbray and fit something that moves with the window, either a Pleated or a Venetian which operate under tension and open with a thumb tab rather than a cord. Alternatively, it would look quite nice if a blind, particularly a Roman blind was fitted right to the top of the wall above the window, at the ceiling. This will allow the blind to be ‘dressed’ to form a valance effect above the window when the blind is open, giving full view from, and use of the window and when it is closed, it will give the illusion of the window being taller. In the case of your bathroom blind, you might like to try a waterproof Roller blind made from PVC fabric. Alternatively, Faux wood blinds are a really great idea, as they have all the look of traditional Wooden blinds, but won't warp in wet or steamy conditions. Admittedly, it is a difficult window to dress and there are not a lot of options, but hopefully, these will give you some ideas. Sarah
...See More
How to reconfigure upstairs for an extra bedroom
Q
Comments (11)
I was looking at an earlier post which showed the whole house because I think you need to think about the whole house. In my opinion however you extend you are limited by how you can do the roof. Although I am sure an architect could come up with innovative solutions I think the second storey at the back can’t be any wider than the lounge is long so to get enough upstairs space I wondered about building forward. (Which falls outside permitted development but may well be allowed) I enclose one option
...See More
Fitting a shower into low ceiling bathroom
Q
Comments (10)
How annoying I wrote a long reply and it didn't post!! Thanks for the replies! Not sure raising the ceiling is an option as it would cost more than we'd gain I think. Interesting to see the different layout ideas. Yes moving the door would mean it would hit the bath. I don't think the hall space would be wide enough for a shower? What do you think? Good to see an idea of how we can reconfigure the toilet sink and bath layout though. I don't think moving the bathroom to the bedroom at the back would be ideal as we'd prefer these rooms to be kept away from the main road. Is it a bad idea to loose a fourth bedroom for a bigger ensuite and bathroom? Is there a way that the fourth bedroom can be reduced in size (but still useable) and making the bathroom (as a minimum) and ensuite bigger?
...See More
Move bathroom upstairs and extend kitchen - proposed layout and costs
Q
Comments (19)
I'd go for option 5 for upstairs as you can make the attic room into a bedroom further down the line. I wouldn't want a windowless bathroom and it'd be easier to run plumbing directly over the former bathroom. Honestly speaking, £11k is not going to cover the upstairs bathroom and kitchen unless you're very handy and are going to do most if this yourself. Even then a new kitchen will blow that budget. I would do the upstairs bathroom and use whatever you have left to rip out the old bathroom suite, lay some lino and have a WC / utility room with the hopes of a bigger renovation of the kitchen/dining/lean-to space further down the line.
...See More
kikiamack
7 years ago
I was wondering if you have spoken to a local estate agent to get their opinion on which option would give most resale value, as they are probably the most likely to know. However, whilst your house is likely to be your biggest investment, it should first and foremost be considered your home. If it would make your life easier and happier to have a dressing room and ensuite, then that is what you should do. You don't say if you have kids, but if they are young and local schools are good you could well be there for a long time. However, if you think you'll only be there for a couple more years then maybe the resale value becomes more important.
Chris L
Original Author
7 years ago
Hi guys, thanks for the comments.

We have 2 young children aged 4 and 18 months. We really like the area but it is far from home for my wife and I as we moved down for my work. Whilst we are settled, there is potential that we could move again in the future due to my job which is why resale is in our mind (we only moved here 2 years ago and took a hit on our previous 2 properties which we lived in for 3 yrs and 4yrs respectively).

The total build costs will be in the region of £100k. We have spoken to a local agent which is what has caused us to rethink! The current plans would add £80k value to house whereas a 4 bed would take it closer to £100k so if we did move in the next couple of years we should get our money back.

We will be also be installing a WC downstairs under the stairs so we would at least have 2 toilets in the house if we don't do en-suite.
Laura Thomas
7 years ago
I agree that a 4 bed house needs a 2nd bathroom or ensuite, while a 3 bed with ensuite and dressing room might seem unnecessary.

I agree with the comment above to speak to a local agent as it does depend on the location of the house as to what will appeal most to buyers.
hortonhearsawho2013
7 years ago
Go for the 4th bedroom. Save the ensuite for a future house. But do install a downstairs WC. And well done on considering resale.
Laura Thomas
7 years ago
Chris you must have commented at the same time as me. Your situation i.e family size and distance from family is the same for us.
Our current project was already a 4 bed (3 doubles and 1 single with good size bathroom). We have room to fit a ensuite in the corner of the master, but the plumbing would have been almost impossible due to solid walls/floors and the soil pipe being opposite side of house. We have tried to future proof for 2 growing daughters by expanding the cloakroom and including a shower - it has been useful too for a muddy dog!
User
7 years ago
defintely a second bathroom. we recently sold and we had 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. it was one of the main selling points as everyone wants more than one bathroom.
Jonathan
7 years ago
Just another thought- if the dressing room and ensuite were swapped for bedroom3 ( so have the main bed and ensuite at the front) you would be in a better situation should you ever put in a loft extension as there is really only one place for the stairs to go...... In my opinion much better to loose a bathroom to extend upwards than loosing a bedroom.
PRO
Design Spec Ltd
7 years ago
Hey Chris!

Some great comments on this one, all could be considered valid!

We generally look at two aspects when considering a resale... The bathroom and the kitchen, both have to be up to the spec of the property and cater for the bedrooms/family size.

When planning a family dwelling for you to live in, having a feature like walk-in wardrobe space and en'suite is a great feature to keep.

We would say make a firm decision on how long you would IDEALLY like to live here and base your end choice on that answer. The only consideration you realistically don't want to alter later on would be the end size of the family bathroom, once these walls and tiles are in place you will not want to ever alter this space.

Please let us know what result you choose!

New World Designers Ltd.

Bigger bathroom v 4th bedroom?

Danielle Garber

Comments (11)

Irene Spinks

A B

Related Discussions

kikiamack

Chris L
Original Author

Laura Thomas

hortonhearsawho2013

Laura Thomas

User

Jonathan

Design Spec Ltd

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Bigger bathroom v 4th bedroom?

Comments (11)

Related Discussions

Chris LOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Chris L
Original Author